Better resume @ LW. Shane Mosley or JLC?

**MANGLER** · 10-10-2009, 02:08 PM

Castillo 4 sho. There were more names there when he was at LW.

**Doctor_Tenma** · 10-10-2009, 02:09 PM

Originally posted by mangler

Castillo 4 sho.

We agree on something.

**Kevin Jesus** · 10-10-2009, 02:12 PM

Mosley's LW resume isn't comparable to Castillo's LW resume.

**MANGLER** · 10-10-2009, 02:13 PM

Originally posted by Dominicano Soy!

We agree on something.

This was obvious as **** El. Given your "is SSM a HOF'er" thread, I ain't surprised at all by this. But assumin you actually just wanted honest opinions and there's no agenda here, it's cool homey.

**The Gambler1981** · 10-10-2009, 02:15 PM

Shane was beating ass at 135 but he really did not fight that strong of competition. Holiday was an ok fighter who Shane won the belt off of but really who was the next best guy he beat John John Molina? Jesse James Leija? Or the great Golden Johnson and Manny Gomez? Shane did his job though and beat the **** out of all those cats though.

JLC fought much stronger opposition at 135 but caught several loses but Stevie Johnston X2, Floyd Mayweather X2, Corrales, Casamayor, Juan Lazcano and Julio Diaz is a pretty good list of opponents.

It really depends on what someone values crushing all the guys you fight even if they are not the greatest or fighting stronger opposition but catching some Ls.

**jrosales13** · 10-10-2009, 02:16 PM

I really don't know. I thought Stevie Johnston bare edged out JLC in both fights. And, I thought Casamayor-JLC was a draw. However, I thought JLC won 7rds against Floyd in the first fight. I thought Floyd won 8rds in the rematch. Corales stopped Castillo in a EPIC fight. But, JLC beat Julio Diaz who was top 5.

While Shane KO'd Leija and Molina. And, has a solid win against Holiday who was top 10 LW at the time.

I think is even. I think if Mosley would of fought Johnston and won. Definnetly Mosley. I think Mosley would of been top 10.

**Al Haymon** · 10-10-2009, 02:16 PM

Originally posted by mangler

Castillo 4 sho. There were more names there when he was at LW.

Castillo by a mile.

**Dynamite Kid** · 10-10-2009, 02:16 PM

Well you can put a big line through his win over Casamayor.

**Al Haymon** · 10-10-2009, 02:17 PM

Originally posted by jrosales13

I really don't know. I thought Stevie Johnston bare edged out JLC in both fights. And, I thought Casamayor-JLC was a draw. However, I thought JLC won 7rds against Floyd in the first fight. I thought Floyd won 8rds in the rematch. Corales stopped Castillo in a EPIC fight. But, JLC beat Julio Diaz who was top 5.

While Shane KO'd Leija and Molina. And, has a solid win against Holiday who was top 10 LW at the time.

I think is even. I think if Mosley would of fought Johnston and won. Definnetly Mosley. I think Mosley would of been top 10.

Those are gatekeepers. Didn't Oscar beat those guys, also?

Better resume @ LW. Shane Mosley or JLC?