Comments Thread For: Tarver Backs Crawford as P4P Best: How Many P4P Champions Has Inoue Defeated?

[YGriffith]

Errol isn't a p4p fighter, it was always supposed to be the winner of the two that gets the spot.

[hugh grant]

Errol isn't a p4p fighter

True, spence isn't a lb 4 lb fighter cos bud is beating the same fighters as spence and bud started at lightweight. So it's clear bud is deservedly the lb 4 lb fighter, and spence is just one of the best at WW whilst not being a lb 4 lb fighter

[joseph5620]

When Inoue beat Donaire, he was the age Crawford was when he beat Spence.

But yeah, Fulton, Rodriguez, Tapales, paper champions. Jeff Horn, Indongo, elite

Same age and at two different stages of their career. That's not how boxing works. Crawford is pound for pound elite. Donaire was not or certainly wasn't at that point.

[joseph5620]

Are you trying to pretend that Donaire and Crawford were at the same stage of their career because they were the same age?

If so, why? It’s overtly disingenuous.

Exactly....

[joseph5620]

Fulton was top 10

Didn’t Spence win a controversial decision against Shawn Porter, in which most boxing fans felt he lost?

That's not even remotely true.

[joseph5620]

Crawford has 0 hof on his resume

inoue has Donair. Period.

Neither one has a HOF fighter on their resume yet. Period.

[HeadShots]

Neither one has a HOF fighter on their resume yet. Period.

Donaire is first ballot. 5 division champ. 2 X bantam weight champ. 2KOOY.


YDKSAB

[hugh grant]

Donaire is first ballot. 5 division champ. 2 X bantam weight champ. 2KOOY.


YDKSAB

Even though he wasn't a pf p fighter when he fought Inoue, donaire had so much experience, had fought so good opponents and learnt off of them, then one can see how he'd give a kid with so little fights under belt issues

[joseph5620]

Donaire is first ballot. 5 division champ. 2 X bantam weight champ. 2KOOY.


YDKSAB

Donaire hasn't been inducted yet and is on no HOF ballots. You can stop lying now.

[Lance98]

You certainly got lower standards for bud than inoue. You don't mind bud campaigning in his 3rd weight class for 5 years before showing he's no1, but you will try justifying your disingenuous behaviours of thought by saying how amazing spence is, so bud is allowed to take 5 years to best him and not be penalised in someway?
Crawl back under the rock you came from

Bud is proven, inoue is unproven and is a very flawed fighter. If you think inoue is no.1, you have very low standards.