Apart from the 1993 version Of Roy Jones Jr...

[djtmal]

If you matchup and compare their resumes Hopkins > Calzaghe, even though they're a weight class lower.

Just look at Echols knocking out Brewer and the many other examples from their resumes.

yeah but calzaghe consistently beating fighters his size or bigger trumps nards little man of the month roster....

[Pullcounter]

Even if that were true, how does that mean he loses to Johnson???

we'lll never know if he loses or wins to johnson cause calz ducked johnson 3x.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

we'lll never know if he loses or wins to johnson cause calz ducked johnson 3x.

The thread asks who you think could beat Calzaghe from Hopkins resume apart from a Prime Roy. Your answer is irrelevent, not to mention inaccurate.

[Chunk..]

That Eubank would get sonned, by any version of Hopkins. Also Kessler imo is a tailor made opponent for Hopkins. A fighter with little upperbody movement, that fights ata measured pace and can be hit. Also this version of Roy Jones would get brutalized by a Hopkins in his 30s.

LOL at any vesion of Hopkins beating Eubank. The same Hopkins who went life and death with Segundo Mercado?! Eubank would beat that verison of Hopkins.

[IMDAZED]

LOL at any vesion of Hopkins beating Eubank. The same Hopkins who went life and death with Segundo Mercado?! Eubank would beat that verison of Hopkins.

You think no version of Hopkins could beat Eubank? Really...you base this on?

[Chunk..]

You think no version of Hopkins could beat Eubank? Really...you base this on?

Read my post again lad.

[IMDAZED]

Read my post again lad.

I read it once - you laughed at the notion that any "vesion" of Hopkins could beat Eubank. Now read my post again...what do you base this on?

FYI: I hope not the first Mercado fight. Because you'll have a tough time explaining to me how any version of Hopkins could lose to a guy who sc****d by Sugar Boy Malinga.

[Kevin Jesus]

Calzaghe beats all the guys on both Hopkins and Jones' resume, imo.

But the James Toney that Jones fought would be the toughest fighter for Calzaghe and maybe even come really close to beating Calzaghe.

[Easy-E]

Potentially, Joe could defeat all of them, but we will never know, given the fact that he never fought any of them...
There are definitly some guys on that list that could potentially beat him based on skill sets, and not weight.

[Kevin Jesus]

But to be fair, both Hopkins and Jones would beat all the fighters on Calzaghe's resume too, imo.