Should there be an ultimate P4P ranking that includes men AND women?

[ProblemChild_JakePaul]

This list would be all about the best boxer regardless of weight class or gender.

My list:

1. Claressa Shields
2. Terence Crawford
3. Canelo Alvarez
4. Terri Harper
5. Jermell Charlo

[_Rexy_]

You can look at he current P4P list like that if you want.



There will never be a woman good enough to make the list, so it doesn't matter.

[ProblemChild_JakePaul]

You can look at he current P4P list like that if you want.



There will never be a woman good enough to make the list, so it doesn't matter.

Yeah but it's adjusted for them being a woman

[_Rexy_]

Yeah but it's adjusted for them being a woman

Meaning what? You just throw them on the list for having a pu$$y?

[The D3vil]

What a terrible list.

You have Terri Harper ranked over Katie Taylor, Chantelle Cameron, Alycia Baumgardner, Seniesa Estrada, and Amanda Serrano?

She literally just got knocked out by Baumgardner a few years ago.

But anyway, if I were to create a P4P list of both genders, which is no more ridiculous than the P4P list itself seeing that Tyson Fury could theoretically murder all other guys on the list, it'd be something like this

1. Oleksandr Usyk
2. Terence Crawford
3. Claressa Shields
4. Naoya Inoue
5. Errol Spence Jr.
6. Amanda Serrano
7. Devin Haney
8. Shakur Stevenson
9. Jermell Charlo
10. Alycia Baumgardner

[buddyr]

so yiou would have Terri Harper, but not the woman that knocked her out and later became undisputed in her weight class? How does that work?

[M312]

That's your favourites list. Nothing to do with P4P.

There are plenty of men the same size as Shields. Any true male professional would knock her out quite easily. It's just nature.

[Teetotaler69]

great shltpost

[Toffee]

Pound 4 Pound, Gender 4 Gender, Disability 4 Disability, Age 4 Age.

We'll end up with some 15 year old trans kid with one arm proclaimed as the best in the world.

The Heavyweight champion is the champion. Even P4P stuff is a work of fantasy.

[Kzbox]

That's ****** no women deserve to be on the p4p they don't have the skills/power for it plus none of their resumes mean shi cuz the divisions are so small and they all fight pretty bad.

If you had this "ultimate p4p list" there would soon be accusations of sexism for not having women on there that don't belong give them an inch and they will take a mile not worth the hassle and just doesn't make sense to do.