In prime, who is the better fighter, COTTO or VARGAS????

[eazy_mas]

Vargas.

Vargas could box and throw powerful straight left.

[bobo_bobo]

Cotto is way better than Vargas. After the Pacquiao fight Cotto's going to be a Hall of Famer, something Vargas can only dream of. Some people here love to hate on Cotto and they are making a fool out of themselves.

[RL_GMA]

Vargas was good, but let's not get it twisted...the dude lost all his big fights.

Mosley (2xs)
De la Hoya
Mayorga
Trinidad

Minus Mayorga, all by KO.

His biggest win was against Winky Wright, and that in itself was a controversial win.

Ya'll wanna just throw Cotto under the bus off GP, but you look even more ****** doing so considering Cotto's level of comp in the last 3 years and yet has only 1 controversial loss.

[Xyei]

I'd say Vargas. He was an absolute beast in his prime even though it was very short.

[IwatchBoxing]

I'd say Vargas. He was an absolute beast in his prime even though it was very short.

like 20 fights short LOL

[WhoreUs]

like 20 fights short LOL

by his 14th fight , vargas had already beaten a top 5 guy in his division , was a champion in his division and was considered #1 at 154.

that's right. by his 14th fight vargas was the #1 guy in his division.

when did cotto become #1 in his division? oh yeah that's right , last year.

how many weeks was he #1 before he got ktfo again?

[IwatchBoxing]

by his 14th fight , vargas had already beaten a top 5 guy in his division , was a champion in his division and was considered #1 at 154.

that's right. by his 14th fight vargas was the #1 guy in his division.

when did cotto become #1 in his division? oh yeah that's right , last year.

how many weeks was he #1 before he got ktfo again?

well, cotto is better peroid. hes the better fighter, smarter fighter, he isnt dumb like vargas, hes overall much better than vargas. if de la hoya can knock him out, so can cotto.

[IwatchBoxing]

even if vargas were to beat cotto, cotto would be overall the better fighter stans!! he beat winky but winky is better overall, and in a rematch, i'd still take winky over him !!

[KittenFlaps]

Cotto.

Vargas isn't even in the same class as Cotto.

[WhoreUs]

well, cotto is better peroid. hes the better fighter, smarter fighter, he isnt dumb like vargas, hes overall much better than vargas. if de la hoya can knock him out, so can cotto.

vargas should have just fought for a bunch of vacant belts.

fighting such elite competition took a lot out of his career.