In prime, who is the better fighter, COTTO or VARGAS????

[andres aza]

vargas

Yea youre sig is one of my favs

[fry91]

vargas duuuuh

[S.G.]

Vargas was a little bigger and he was immensely talented before it all went wrong

Vargas has some good wins too, particularly Winky and Quartey, but Cotto's resume is superior IMO

[-EX-]

Cotto has better wins but Vargas may be a little more skilled and talented...

It'd be a pretty good fight IMO...I'd lean towards Vargas

But Cotto isn't a Junior Middleweight...

[jri9d0]

Vargas. Vargas would not be an underdog against Pacquiao, and would not struggle with Clottey.

Really? Based on what, a shaky chin and wounded confidence? Your hatred for Cotto really distorts any logic to truth. It’s a good thing you’re just a message border and not a true pro-boxing pundit, your credibility would have plummeted faster than the Teddy Atlas jinx.

Peace.

[tito yuca]

Cotto has better wins but Vargas may be a little more skilled and talented...

It'd be a pretty good fight IMO...I'd lean towards Vargas

But Cotto isn't a Junior Middleweight...

What wins on Cotto's resume are better than Winky and Quartey?

[tito yuca]

Really? Based on what, a shaky chin and wounded confidence? Your hatred for Cotto really distorts any logic to truth. It’s a good thing you’re just a message border and not a true pro-boxing pundit, your credibility would have plummeted faster than the Teddy Atlas jinx.

Peace.

Shaky chin? Vargas was never knocked down until he fought Tito, p4p one of the hardest punchers ever. Cotto was put down by Torres and Margarito, HARDLY Tito-like punchers.

[jri9d0]

What wins on Cotto's resume are better than Winky and Quartey?

Come on, even a boxing educated head like yourself has to admit that the Winky win was a fluke; though I give Vargas full credit for the Quartey scrap.

Peace.

[-EX-]

What wins on Cotto's resume are better than Winky and Quartey?

Well I'd pick even the version of Mosley that Cotto fought to beat Quartey but I mean as a whole his resume is better...

[tantaran69]

OMG, besides J.Castillejo and Ike who else he fought and beat on a no questions way. Winky? watch that fight plz. Yori? overrated when he step up on quality he got beat up. Don't get me wrong I used 2 lov this guy, even I was kind of uuuujjjj when he was fightning Tito...