Comparison of May, Pac and Nelo

[Silence]

Pac's entire WW career is sketchy AF
Prior to that it's filled with farmers and food vendors.

Nelo's story is ongoing

As of now

May, Nelo, Pac...Pac (AKA CW King) has too many issues with his big names*.

Pac is very flawed fighter. This is why people still don't rank him as GOAT despite his some ridiculous records. He is the worst fighter here in terms of defensive skills, chin, one punch power, punch accuracy and timing. He got too much punishment and KO losses in his career. He got outboxed. I also think his ring IQ and generalship wasn't that good.

May > Nelo > Pac in terms of H2H

[BodyBagz]

Pac is very flawed fighter. This is why people still don't rank him as GOAT despite his some ridiculous records. He is the worst fighter here in terms of defensive skills, chin, one punch power, punch accuracy and timing. He got too much punishment and KO losses in his career. He got outboxed. I also think his ring IQ and generalship wasn't that good.

May > Nelo > Pac in terms of H2H

But he's ''humble''

[djtmal]

Pac's entire WW career is sketchy AF
Prior to that it's filled with farmers and food vendors.

Nelo's story is ongoing

As of now

May, Nelo, Pac...Pac (AKA CW King) has too many issues with his big names*.

Everybody Floyd fought they either had to roll in the ring in a wheelchair, or teach basic boxing 3 weeks before the fight

[BodyBagz]

Everybody Floyd fought they either had to roll in the ring in a wheelchair, or teach basic boxing 3 weeks before the. fight

With a sad assed resume like Pac's how did he manage to lose so many times ?
Pac was a left handed Gatti

[QueensburyRules]

H2H/boxing skills/talent/less flaws:
May > Nelo > Pac

Resume: (based on big names)
Pac > May > Nelo

Resume: (based on champions)
Pac (22) = May (22) > Nelo (18)

Title defense:
May (18) > Pac (15) > Nelo (13)

Pac is clearly most flawed fighter here in terms of bad moments, defensive skills, chin etc. but he is arguably greatest among three.

Canelo is between May and Pac in terms of ability imo. His worst moments were against May and Bivol. Golovkin and Lara fights were tough too. All of them are H2H monsters not bums. He is still only 31.

May is clearly the most flawless fighter here. But, also most dirty. He uses clinching too much. Still the best imo.

- - Manny the best 40 yr old win against prime Thurman ducked by l'l floydy during the whole of their overlapping careers.

Nelo soon retiring after checking off all his to do list is arguably the greatest of the bunch.

l'l floydy retired after eating 111 punches from a debut fighter before knocking out another debutante in what was supposed to be an exhibition that, ahem, he ducked after signing to be nursed back to Japan.

Then Logan whooping him a new one.

Guess they don't make TBEs the way they used to!

[Silence]

But he's ''humble''

He is humble, hero (for entire Asia) and successful guy. But, he can't become GOAT. He has arguments for top 10 tho.

[BodyBagz]

He is humble, hero (for entire Asia) and successful guy. But, he can't become GOAT. He has arguments for top 10 tho.

Being humble is nice but it shouldn't cover up a weak resume.

[QueensburyRules]

Being humble is nice but it shouldn't cover up a weak resume.

- - l'l floydy fighting U bodybag contents pitiable.

[Silence]

Being humble is nice but it shouldn't cover up a weak resume.

Floyd's resume is super duper neither. Pac beat De La Hoya, Cotto and Mosley better. Floyd beat Marquez better. Pac fought better Mosley, Cotto and Marquez versions.

[BodyBagz]

Floyd's resume is super duper neither. Pac beat De La Hoya, Cotto and Mosley better. Floyd beat Marquez better. Pac fought better Mosley, Cotto and Marquez versions.

Here is where we disagree

The versions of DLH*, Mosley and Cotto* that Pac beat were the inferior versions.
May only needed 1 fight with JMM to end the ''series''. One n done
May would definitely have an 0 if he had Pac's exact resume.
Pac would get exposed during the PBF stage of May's career.

Can you imagine the shlt May would get if he fought Horn ????
And allow himself to get robbed ????

This is not up for debate, sry.