Comparison of May, Pac and Nelo

[Silence]

Question

how can Floyd not have the best resume when he beat the other 2 and neither has as good win on their resume?

Pac was granddad. Nelo was grandson. He should have beaten Nelo at fully 154 not 152 BS.

[hugh grant]

Pac beating Thurman trumps Floyd whole ww/jmw resume

So true. Pacs win over a prime thurman trumps anything Floyd did at Ww/jmw, and Pac will historically go down as a greater WW than floyd. But we give credit where it's due. Floyd will go down in history as a better light middleweight than pac.

[LeOoze]

So true. Pacs win over a prime thurman trumps anything Floyd did at Ww/jmw, and Pac will historically go down as a greater WW than floyd. But we give credit where it's due. Floyd will go down in history as a better light middleweight than pac.

And the better 147lber since he beat him at that weight class

[gamesworn]

Canelo skill better than Pacquiao? I don't remember a shutout loss of Pacquiao, his losses were always competitive and no one really dominated him. Canelo on the hand, had bad losses again Mayweather and Bivol, who shut him down completely. Canelo has the better chin but skill, Pacquiao is better.

[hugh grant]

And the better 147lber since he beat him at that weight class

and this is where Floyd fans logic fails. So Floyd is the greater WW historically as he has a win over pac? Is that really it?
How about give Pac s trilogy and let Pac beat you 2 out of 3 times? Floyd fans will usually respond with Pac was an easy beat and Floyd beats Pac 10 out of 10 times.
These are the lines of debate you usually get with a Floyd fan

[LeOoze]

and this is where Floyd fans logic fails. So Floyd is the greater WW historically as he has a win over pac? Is that really it?
How about give Pac s trilogy and let Pac beat you 2 out of 3 times? Floyd fans will usually respond with Pac was an easy beat and Floyd beats Pac 10 out of 10 times.
These are the lines of debate you usually get with a Floyd fan

Floyd also beat Judah, Mosley (when he was lineal), Maidana, and JMM at 147.

[djtmal]

Floyd also beat Judah, Mosley (when he was lineal), Maidana, and JMM at 147.

So Floyd is a top ten all time great welterweight because he beat Judah Mosley Madonna and Marquez a lightweight

[LeOoze]

So Floyd is a top ten all time great welterweight because he beat Judah Mosley Madonna and Marquez a lightweight

throw Pac in the mix too. Also I never said he’s a top 10 147lber, but he’s ahead of Pac. That is all

[BodyBagz]

Pac's entire WW career is sketchy AF
Prior to that it's filled with farmers and food vendors.

Nelo's story is ongoing

As of now

May, Nelo, Pac...Pac (AKA CW King) has too many issues with his big names*.

[GhostofDempsey]

Floyd’s claim to fame is retiring at 50-0, which isn’t that big a deal when you’ve cherry picked your entire career. Achieving titles in 8 weight classes or becoming undisputed is bigger.