Give a Solid Argument for Why Either Charlo or Andrade Deserves a Canelo Fight

[Keysandboxing]

I'm on this forum to grow my understanding of the sport I love. With that said, I want someone to provide an honest, non-bias, accomplishment based argument for why Canelo SHOULD fight Andrade or Charlo. Oh let's try and keep race out of this, I'm an African American man who's an avid Canelo, Andrade, and Charlo fan. As a fan I want to see Canelo fight those guys, and to shut the mouths of the haters, I really want to see those fights, but I don't think either guy deserves it. I mean everyone gets mad at Canelo for the fights not happening but how long has Andrade and Charlo been in or around the same division. Those guys are scared of losing their sacred "0", which you can thank Mayweather for. Here's why neither deserves the fight based on accomplishments:

Charlo:
-has fought b and c level competition at best.
-beat Julian Williams in amazing fashion, but Williams went on to look subpar, and, with respect to Breadman, is a chinny fighter
-two division world champ, but he only earned one of his belts by beating Cornelius Bundrage, the other belt he was elevated from interim title holder - never unified titles

Andrade: I'll try and keep it short
- two division world champ, never unified
- has a tendency to look terrible against b and c level opposition
-only won vacant titles
- the big kicker is.....he never fought an active world champion to win a title.. something Canelo had already did before he even fought Mayweather.

[Boxing fan1981]

Because they’re black. The end.

[Boxing fan1981]

Just joking by the way.

I have no serious response because I can’t think of a reason.

Charlo goes life and death against 154lbers. Andrade hasn’t fought anyone elite, ever.

[Madison Boxing]

because they are simply better fighters than the recent guys canelo has fought with the styles to cause him problems

[SUBZER0ED]

Because they're undefeated title holders. This sport is in fact called PRIZE FIGHTING. To say that undefeated champions don't "deserve" a fight with another champion, just boggles the mind. Who came up with this crap? I mean, Canelo has beaten people easily that he SHOULD have beaten and fought only one who some people thought might beat him (Golovkin). He doesn't have this long list of tough fights where he had to dig deep to win. So, what makes him so special that dictates other champions must "earn" a fight against him?

[Thuglife Nelo]

fellas, all jokes aside, Canelo would beat these two on the same night! We need to go back to them Foreman Exhibition nights.

First Fight, Charlo: Canelo breaks his body down. Stops in 6th Round.

Second Fight, Andrade: Runs for 10 rounds around the ring while Canelo leans back on his corner yawning. Canelo stops him in Round 12.

After hours: Precise Presenter uploads a video and cries to Mr. BDA that his life is fake.

And that's all she wrote!

[Toscano]

And the reason for Macabu deserving the fight is...?

[Boxing fan1981]

Because they're undefeated title holders. This sport is in fact called PRIZE FIGHTING. To say that undefeated champions don't "deserve" a fight with another champion, just boggles the mind. Who came up with this crap? I mean, Canelo has beaten people easily that he SHOULD have beaten and fought only one who some people thought might beat him (Golovkin). He doesn't have this long list of tough fights where he had to dig deep to win. So, what makes him so special that dictates other champions must "earn" a fight against him?

What you’re saying does make sense, except Canelo fights champions and bypasses other champions to then fight more champions.

MFr is fighting champion after champion.

Did Andrade deserve to be the champion to fight Canelo over Caleb Plant, the other champion? No.

Did Charlo deserve it more than Callum or Bjs, also champions? No.

[Boxing fan1981]

And the reason for Macabu deserving the fight is...?

Easy, he’s a 200lb cruiserweight champion.

Bigger challenge and Canelo becomes a 5 weight class champion. History.

[El_Mero]

When Saul was at 160, he said he wanted all the belts.