Comments Thread For: Why Pound-For-Pounds Lists Are All Meaningless

[removed]

I'd love to see that fight. Canelo absolutely wrecks Joshua and makes him quit even if Canelo is at a significant weight disadvantage.

Are you on the wind-up? AJ would leave him in a bodybag.

[Combat Talk Radio]

Let's put Canelo in with AJ then.

I'd love to see that fight. Canelo absolutely wrecks Joshua and makes him quit even if Canelo is at a significant weight disadvantage.

[removed]

And saying "Tyson Fury is the best boxer in the world because nobody from any division can beat him in a fight" isn't?

Fury is ranked #1 in the HW division and has been for ages, which makes him the best in the division until someone beats him or he retires.

But yeah, who can beat him? Usyk? AJ? They both get demolished.

[BarfyMan362]

Speculation. Fury is ranked #1

And saying "Tyson Fury is the best boxer in the world because nobody from any division can beat him in a fight" isn't?

[M312]

P4P list these days is just who your favourite boxers are. Maybe based on resume, maybe not.

It was supposed to be to measure stick of 'if everyone was the same size, who would win', but that concept seems completely out the window

[elfag]

p4p list is as natural as anything in boxing. Of course its going to be subjective. Hell the scoring of a lot of fights is subjective and people argue over score cards. Its completely natural for boxing fans to ask who was the best and especially who was the best across different eras and different weight classes.


If you got say usyk and lomachenko, then its goign to be natural to look at them as a boxing fan and say hey who do you think is the best ukrainian boxing fighter today. Why not, what is wrong with that? I mean we watch sports for fun.

[MrShakeAndBake]

Lennox is far and away the best UK HW ever on both resume and ability. Fury is no2 already but that says as much about UK HWs as it does him tbh, if he was to retire tomorrow I dont think hes done enough to be solidified as a top 10 all time HW. Theres a lot of fights out there for him. And whether you consider Wilder to be the 2nd best HW or not, theres no denying he is kind of a stylistic anomaly.



He cant be the baddest man on the planet when he'd struggle to make it out of the first round against third tier HWs in MMA and kickboxing.

Lennox was the best heavyweight ever, and thats coming from Klitschko fan..

[MrShakeAndBake]

BUT WHEN IDIOTS HAD LOMACHENKO AS THE NUMBER ONE P4P IN THE WORLD IDIOTS IN THIS WEBSITE INCLUDING KEITH IDEC DIDNT CARE ABOUT OTHER PEOPLES PERSPECTIVE. THEY HAD NO PROBLEM HAVING LOMA AS THE BEST ♂️ WHY? WHO KNOWS. Color COMPLEXION??? PROBABLY

Here is my "orher peoples" perspective for "other idiots" outhere... CLENELO ALVAROIDS should not even be mentioned in a p4p list because he got caught using PEDS.
How about them apples? or berries

[TMLT87]

Lennox is far and away the best UK HW ever on both resume and ability. Fury is no2 already but that says as much about UK HWs as it does him tbh, if he was to retire tomorrow I dont think hes done enough to be solidified as a top 10 all time HW. Theres a lot of fights out there for him. And whether you consider Wilder to be the 2nd best HW or not, theres no denying he is kind of a stylistic anomaly.

Yes, it is true, it's meaningless, but once in a blue moon nice to chat about for fun. Take your pick of pound for pound, but Fury is the king of all boxing (baddest man on the planet)

He cant be the baddest man on the planet when he'd struggle to make it out of the first round against third tier HWs in MMA and kickboxing.

[removed]

I can think of a few who can beat him in his own division

Speculation. Fury is ranked #1