Who does better against Roy Jones at 154lb: Floyd or Manny?

[MONGOOSE66]

Please tell me your opinion on this fantasy fight..do you believe floyd pot shots his way to a decision over a prime Roy Jones?

Or does Floyd do to Roy what he did to gatti and corales?

IF U KNEW boxing AND boxed. You’d know weight classes are their for a reason. Smaller men will ALWAYS BE FASTER then big men. Ive seen 200 pound men get embarrassed by bantam weights. DOES IT MEAN they can really whip him in a 12 round fight. NO…….. save your hypotheticals for the kids.

[Motofan]

So basically who lasts longer before getting stopped? Floyd has superior defense and wouldn’t be attacking like Pacman so he likely lasts longer. Both get stopped at the time of Roy’s choosing.

[War Room]

Obviously, Roy would be considerably bigger than both guys especially Manny... But technically, both Manny and Floyd did fight at 154lb...

I don't think even with Floyd's masterful defense and great movement he could avoid an all out assault by Roy... Floyd wouldn't be able to pot shot his way to victory like he always does (at least later in his career).... Thus he would have to FIGHT Roy...

Both Manny and Floyd have great chins and I think they could fight with Roy toe to toe for a while before the inevitable (either ref stoppage or KO)...

But would Manny be better equipped to actually fight Roy toe to toe... Manny has almost a similar level of output as Roy as far as throwing huge combinations. Manny LIKES to trade fire with fire... But prime Roy LOVES to trade fire with fire as well.

Now, Roy probably has the ability to pot shot his way to victory with both Floyd and Manny, but in this scenario assume that Roy is just going to fight toe to toe.

So in a toe to toe fight, who has a better chance against Roy?

I didn't even read past the title. You're cracked out of your mind. Stop doing drugs, get cleaned up.

[Stuntman Mike]

IF U KNEW boxing AND boxed. You’d know weight classes are their for a reason. Smaller men will ALWAYS BE FASTER then big men. Ive seen 200 pound men get embarrassed by bantam weights. DOES IT MEAN they can really whip him in a 12 round fight. NO…….. save your hypotheticals for the kids.

The 200 pound man was he by any chance completely novice against someone with a bit more skill

We are talking about Roy Jones here,the guy has the best footwork,angle making fastest most powerful hands pound 4 pound (to this day)

He would toy with any welterweight in history

You try and act all high and mighty like some great knowledgeable boxing expert just because you know that smaller men are faster than bigger men? Problem with that is distance and closing it my friend

That's basic knowledge and your vague sideline opinion is abosiute dog****

Also if you don't want to give an opinion on the ts subject and suggest we save the topic for kids then what are you doing in here

It's a bit of fun and a playful discussion...you need to take your meds and calm down

[MONGOOSE66]

The 200 pound man was he by any chance completely novice against someone with a bit more skill

We are talking about Roy Jones here,the guy has the best footwork,angle making fastest most powerful hands pound 4 pound (to this day)

He would toy with any welterweight in history

You try and act all high and mighty like some great knowledgeable boxing expert just because you know that smaller men are faster than bigger men? Problem with that is distance and closing it my friend

That's basic knowledge and your vague sideline opinion is abosiute dog****

Also if you don't want to give an opinion on the ts subject and suggest we save the topic for kids then what are you doing in here

It's a bit of fun and a playful discussion...you need to take your meds and calm down

Your awful sensitive. Is it that time if the month?

[eco1]

Prime Roy would win both fights.

[Stuntman Mike]

Your awful sensitive. Is it that time if the month?

That's it then jog on to another thread and tell people you don't want to be involved

I told you to calm down and you turn it round and say something similar

You really need to get that head checked and lay off the drugs you're not the smartest cookie

[Stuntman Mike]

So basically who lasts longer before getting stopped? Floyd has superior defense and wouldn’t be attacking like Pacman so he likely lasts longer. Both get stopped at the time of Roy’s choosing.

Nah he asked who would do better in your opinion ..whether better is lasting longer and not firing back then getting tkod or whether attacking and eventually getting stopped but doing more damage is better is totally subjective but that's basically what he's asking

[MONGOOSE66]

That's it then jog on to another thread and tell people you don't want to be involved

I told you to calm down and you turn it round and say something similar

You really need to get that head checked and lay off the drugs you're not the smartest cookie

U still sound so upset. Change your pad and take a Pamprin. You’ll feel much better. Maybe doing the old man would do u some good. U sound frustrated.

[Stuntman Mike]

U still sound so upset. Change your pad and take a Pamprin. You’ll feel much better. Maybe doing the old man would do u some good. U sound frustrated.

We are discussing boxing or fantasy boxing in here whatever you want to call it .

All you're looking for is reactions to make your sad little day glimmer with some form of significance or to be recognised instead of passed unnoticed like every other