So if Floyd simply destroys JMM, does he have the upper hand on Pacquiao?

[Ishy Aytan]

Of course the Pac fans will argue that Pac beat him at his very best weight. But this is the same arguement that the Floyd fans use when questioning Pacs victories over Oscar.

Floyd and his fans argue that he beat him at 154, his very best weight. But after Pac beat Oscar and Hatton, apparently Floyds credentials went down because Pac did a better job on both of them than him.

But can Floyd use the same arguement if he destroys JMM? Obviously people will critisize the victory, but is it right for people to go crazy over Pacs victory over Oscar, in which he was clearly weight drained and for those who dont believe he was they should compare the photos from the pac weigh in to another at any fight at 154.

Now my question is, will Floyd's credentials over Pac increase if Floyd beats or destroys JMM?

[2501]

Of course the Pac fans will argue that Pac beat him at his very best weight. But this is the same arguement that the Floyd fans use when questioning Pacs victories over Oscar.

Floyd and his fans argue that he beat him at 154, his very best weight. But after Pac beat Oscar and Hatton, apparently Floyds credentials went down because Pac did a better job on both of them than him.

But can Floyd use the same arguement if he destroys JMM? Obviously people will critisize the victory, but is it right for people to go crazy over Pacs victory over Oscar, in which he was clearly weight drained and for those who dont believe he was they should compare the photos from the pac weigh in to another at any fight at 154.

Now my question is, will Floyd's credentials over Pac increase if Floyd beats or destroys JMM?

Ah, didnt know Hatton came down from JWW to fight Pac. What weight did they fight at again?

[Klitschko2010]

If Floyd destroys JMM of course he will be the favourite over Pac.

[Jim Jeffries]

I don't remember Marquez jumping up two weight classes to fight Pacquiao. And Pac beat Hatton at his best weight.

[UnDeniable]

I have this weird feeling that people will say it means nothing but yet say Pac beat Hatton and Oscar better than Floyd which somehow proves something

I can see this happening

[Ishy Aytan]

I don't remember Marquez jumping up two weight classes to fight Pacquiao. And Pac beat Hatton at his best weight.

And i dont remember me saying Pac didnt fight Hatton at Hattons best weight. Read it again and you'll find that i'm talking about Oscar.

Did Pac fight Oscar at Oscars best weight???????????????????????

[larry x]

they wont give floyd the credit he deserves..but in the same breath they'll say pacman can beat floyd

[Guest]

I think he would have the upper hand.

It's amazing how many times Floyd and if are in the same sentence though.

[Ishy Aytan]

I have this weird feeling that people will say it means nothing but yet say Pac beat Hatton and Oscar better than Floyd which somehow proves something

I can see this happening

Yep this is what has already started. Some how guys on here got confused with me talking about Oscar with Hatton.

[Jim Jeffries]

And i dont remember me saying Pac didnt fight Hatton at Hattons best weight. Read it again and you'll find that i'm talking about Oscar.

Did Pac fight Oscar at Oscars best weight???????????????????????

WW was Oscar's best weight, if I'm not mistaken. He looked very good at 150 months prior. Not Pac's fault he didn't rehydrate (though he did have IV marks) enough afterward.