10 greatest SMW ever?

[Adamantium]

In no particular order:

Toney
Jones
Benn
Calzaghe

[D-MiZe]

Who has Roy fought at SMW?

Calzaghe is the best SMW ever.

[Grand Champ]

Toney and RJJ just weren't in the division long enough to warrant such high a ranking.

Toney's best win is Iran Barkley and had a bad loss to RJJ where he looked like ****.

I agree with this. I would even put Kessler over James Toney and perhaps even RJJ because their reign in SMW was short. My top 5 might be

1. Calzaghe
2. Eubank
3. Benn
4. Kessler
5. RJJ

[Porter's Dad]

Think about it for a second Toney's best win at 168 was Iran barkley who got KTFO by Benn in 1 round 2 years before.

oh and Toney was 5 rounds down on all three cards when Barkley's corner pulled him out before the start of round 11, all he had to do was stay stood up to win a wide UD.

Classic. He's probably read about how Toney was lucky to beat Nunn (big myth, btw, Toney slowly broke down Nunn), and then thought he'd run with it here.

[Steak]

I dont know how people are saying that Toney 'did nothing' at SMW.

Iran Barkley was rated #2 in the world at 168.
Tony Thorton was rated #8 at 168.
Tim Littles was rated #5.
and Charles Williams was rated around #4 at Light Heavyweight.

Im not saying he should be rated higher than Calzaghe or anything, but thats fairly solid opposition.

surprisingly, the only top ten guys that Calzaghe faced in his Super Middleweight reign were Robin Reid #6, Richie Woodhall #8, Charles Brewer #5, Byron Mitchell #5, Lacy #3, Peter Manfredo #10, and of course Kessler #2.

not too many guys, considering how long he defended his title.

the top ten guys Kessler beat were Mundine #3, Beyer #4, and Andrade #10.

and I know hes not that recongnisable, but dont forget about Chong Pal Park. Liles had an ok run too.

[Benncollinsaad]

Personally, I do think Nigel Benn was a greater smw than Toney. If they had met back in '94 it would be quite a war!

[Allucard]

What would be your pick? Here is my top 10 ATG Super MW list:

Roy Jones
James Toney
Chris Eubank
Nigel Benn
Steve Collins
Michael Nunn
Joe Calzaghe
Mikkel Kessler
Frankie Liles
Merqui Sosa

I'm not counting Michael Watson because he fought only one fight at SMW.

Fixed it for you.

[Chr0nic]

Who has Roy fought at SMW?

Calzaghe is the best SMW ever.

who has calzaghe fought in smw?

[D-MiZe]

who has calzaghe fought in smw?

Everybody that was somebody.

[Chr0nic]

Everybody that was somebody.

any one that just sticks around throughout his whole career in supermiddle weight is a nobody