10 greatest SMW ever?

[The Monk]

Love him or hate him, Calzaghe is greatest super middle weight of all time. His achievements at the weight are unparalleled.

[BattlingNelson]

any one that just sticks around throughout his whole career in supermiddle weight is a nobody

What if someone stuck around at middle? Would he also be a nobody?

[Chr0nic]

What if someone stuck around at middle? Would he also be a nobody?

no he would'nt

[BattlingNelson]

no he would'nt

Why the difference?

Any other divisions that also only provides nobodies?

[Grand Champ]

Why the difference?

Any other divisions that also only provides nobodies?

Difference is his name is Calzaghe and not Bernard Hopkins.

[Spray_resistant]

Calzaghe is the best SMW of all time there is no one who accomplished as much as he did in that weight class. Arguments for fighters like RJJ and Toney are weak because they were not in the division long even though their career legacies as a whole trump Joe's. Still, Joe is the Standard bearer at 168.

[WhoreUs]

1. nigel benn
2. nigel benn
3. nigel benn
4. nigel benn
5. nigel benn
6. nigel benn
7. nigel benn
8. nigel benn
9. nigel benn
10. omar sheika

[D-MiZe]

any one that just sticks around throughout his whole career in supermiddle weight is a nobody

Hmm, I thought he embarrassed Roy at LHW.

[Benncollinsaad]

1. nigel benn
2. nigel benn
3. nigel benn
4. nigel benn
5. nigel benn
6. nigel benn
7. nigel benn
8. nigel benn
9. nigel benn
10. omar sheika

Nice list! Except for nr.10.