10 greatest SMW ever?

[NakiFan]

Yeah op list is good, Calzaghe is #1 by a good way

[Sick/]

What would be your pick? Here is my top 10 ATG Super MW list:

Roy Jones
James Toney
Joe Calzaghe
Nigel Benn
Steve Collins
Chris Eubank
Michael Nunn
Frankie Liles
Mikkel Kessler
Merqui Sosa

I'm not counting Michael Watson because he fought only one fight at SMW.

LOL at benn and Collins over Eubank. Eubank should be at least 2 higher.

Calzaghe should be no 1 too

[catalinul]

How the fcuk can you put James Toney over Calzaghe at 168?

He only fought at the weight 7 times and Ricky Slackhouse, Doug DeWitt, Iran Barkley, Tony Thompson, Tim Littles and Charles Williams are hardly awe inspiring names, in fact only Barkley (a MW) and Littles (a prospect who never amounted to anything) where even top 10 168lbers.



then he lost to RJJ.

Rankins aren't based only on resume.

[REMOVED SHARK 97]

but i blew my load a while back...

...

[Sick/]

calzaghe
roy jones jnr
eubank
benn
collins

Good pick

but Eubank at super middle > Roy

[S A M U R A I]

Joe >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 168.



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

[hammerhiem]

Rankins aren't based only on resume.

yes they are, resume is everything, everything else is sugar coating and opinion.

Toney and RJJ did fcuk all at SMW, and while you can argue P4P they are better than Calzaghe no fcuking way are they better 168lbers.

Think about it for a second Toney's best win at 168 was Iran barkley who got KTFO by Benn in 1 round 2 years before.

oh and Toney was 5 rounds down on all three cards when Barkley's corner pulled him out before the start of round 11, all he had to do was stay stood up to win a wide UD.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Calzaghe hands down, skills wise he could of hang with any SMW and accomplishments wise, he ****s on any SMW.
Unified, lineal champ with 20 straight succesfull title defense, plus won every ****ing major title at the weight.

This is a no contest really, unless you area Calzaghe hater

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Rankins aren't based only on resume.

Exactly.
You have to take take into account Accomplishments and Skills.

Skills wise Calzaghe can hang with Tony, Accomplishments wise, he ****s on Toiny!!!!!!!

[catalinul]

yes they are, resume is everything, everything else is sugar coating and opinion.

Toney and RJJ did fcuk all at SMW, and while you can argue P4P they are better than Calzaghe no fcuking way are they better 168lbers.

Think about it for a second Toney's best win at 168 was Iran barkley who got KTFO by Benn in 1 round 2 years before.

oh and Toney was 5 rounds down on all three cards when Barkley's corner pulled him out before the start of round 11, all he had to do was stay stood up to win a wide UD.

I disagree.

Personally I think they should be based on resume,accomplishments and H2H ability.

But each to his own.