Do you think JOEL CASAMAYOR is done?

[JM1]

he looked good enough against JMM to compete at the top level still

he should not retire on that loss imo

but hes aging. theres no problem with the old guys competing but when he get stopped along his journey then the fighter should think twice imo

[KJB]

I think it depends on the opponent. Against the right one he can win on experience and slip his way to victory.

Yeah, but either way he still doesnt have many of those left, definitely not at the top level. He has been sliding clearly over his last three fights, punctuated with his first ever KO loss to Marquez. He isnt getting any younger.

[johncods]

he's done.. he got his ass beat by santa cruz prior to the JMM fight.. And got a gift that was probably the clearest robbery i've seen. and he fought for his life against michael katsidis aka little hatton prior to those 2.

[Bhopreign]

he's done.. he got his ass beat by santa cruz prior to the JMM fight.. And got a gift that was probably the clearest robbery i've seen. and he fought for his life against michael katsidis aka little hatton prior to those 2.

You gotta watch that fight close like I did the second time, I had Casa by a point, Cruz was landing nothing.

[catalinul]

At the leve we were adjusted to seeing him compete he is.

But he can still fight and beat some guys.I'd pick him to beat Barrios.I'd give him good chances with Valero.

He beats Escobedo.

He should fight Rolando Reyes or Antonio DeMarco.

I also love him and always was a fan.

[johncods]

You gotta watch that fight close like I did the second time, I had Casa by a point, Cruz was landing nothing.

Maybe I need to but watching the fight live the 1st time there was no way casa could have won that. santa cruz was outworking and outlanding him and i was surprised he was being dominated like that.

[Santo Domingo]

i think he is. how old is he now? 37? 38?

Casa is listed at 38. Which means he is 41.

Cuban/caribbean/Dominican ages.

[Bhopreign]

Maybe I need to but watching the fight live the 1st time there was no way casa could have won that. santa cruz was outworking and outlanding him and i was surprised he was being dominated like that.

I felt the same way and was so mad at the decision, I downloaded it here on Boxingscene and could see how he go it, I still think the job may have been in though, who knows. I didnt see Cruz landing cleanly.

[MatchMaker215]

I honestly think hes done,btw,TS,not flaming or anything,but why do you put a U in favorite?Are u from the UK or DR?Again not flamin or anything

[Santo Domingo]

I honestly think hes done,btw,TS,not flaming or anything,but why do you put a U in favorite?Are u from the UK or DR?Again not flamin or anything

Yes. American English is my second (third?) language. So it's colour, favourite, theatre. Sorry.