If dlh got the nod in

[dans]

the tito fight and shane2 fight would he be an atg?

Valid point but he did get the nod against Quartey which was a fight I think he lost. He had a huge 12th round, but it doesn't excuse the fact that he was beaten to the punch and outboxed for the majority of the fight.

[dans]

Oh yeah, he should've lost to Felix Sturm too.

Not taking anything away from DLH, just saying.

I quote the ATG hockey movie, "The Mighty Ducks":

"A quarter of an inch and it would've gone in!"

"Yeah but a quarter of an inch the other way and you would've missed completely"

[JAB5239]

Valid point but he did get the nod against Quartey which was a fight I think he lost. He had a huge 12th round, but it doesn't excuse the fact that he was beaten to the punch and outboxed for the majority of the fight.

I haven't seen that fight since forever, but I remember thinking Quartey was ahead by a point going into the 12th, and the knockdown cost him the fight.

[dans]

I haven't seen that fight since forever, but I remember thinking Quartey was ahead by a point going into the 12th, and the knockdown cost him the fight.

Watch it again if you can. On my card, DLH needed a KO or at least a couple KDs to pull it out. Quartey got robbed IMO.

[dans]

Watch it again if you can. On my card, DLH needed a KO or at least a couple KDs to pull it out. Quartey got robbed IMO.

Quartey should have wins over De La Hoya and Vernon Forrest.

[S.G.]

Valid point but he did get the nod against Quartey which was a fight I think he lost. He had a huge 12th round, but it doesn't excuse the fact that he was beaten to the punch and outboxed for the majority of the fight.

Oh yeah, he should've lost to Felix Sturm too.

Not taking anything away from DLH, just saying.

I quote the ATG hockey movie, "The Mighty Ducks":

"A quarter of an inch and it would've gone in!"

"Yeah but a quarter of an inch the other way and you would've missed completely"

Felix Sturm, yes, but please don't insinuate the Quartey fight was a robbery in the same vein

It was very close and competetive, but personally i had Oscar up even before the 12th

It's a different kettle of fish to Oscar/Sturm, Oscar/Tito and Oscar/Mosley II, all of which having genuinely involved robberies

[AztecWanker]

Valid point but he did get the nod against Quartey which was a fight I think he lost. He had a huge 12th round, but it doesn't excuse the fact that he was beaten to the punch and outboxed for the majority of the fight.

I haven't seen that fight since forever, but I remember thinking Quartey was ahead by a point going into the 12th, and the knockdown cost him the fight.

Thank you. I thought I was the only one that thought Ike beat him.

[MANGLER]

Thank you. I thought I was the only one that thought Ike beat him.

I thought Ike beat him too.

[dans]

Felix Sturm, yes, but please don't insinuate the Quartey fight was a robbery in the same vein

It was very close and competetive, but personally i had Oscar up even before the 12th

It's a different kettle of fish to Oscar/Sturm, Oscar/Tito and Oscar/Mosley II, all of which having genuinely involved robberies

We're both entitled to opinions, both are valid.

I personally think people gave DLH pity rounds against Quartey. Rounds where he didn't win but performed better than in previous rounds. I can't remember exactly but I think I had Quartey winning like 8 out of the first 10 rounds or something.

I don't think it's different than those Oscar fights at all. I would argue that the Quartey fight was a bigger robbery than the Mosley fight. Even though DLH got a 10-8 round in the 12th, it wasn't enough to win. Quartey knew it too, not that it says anything. But honestly I think people sleep on that as a robbery, it was IMO.

[Mr. Fantastic]

I thought DLH barely won against Quartey. The knockdown in the 12th is what edged him the victory. My opinion. I wouldn't call it robbed....robbed is the Trinidad/Mosley2 fights.