@ 140lbs, Who Comes Out On Top...

[Doctor_Tenma]

Floyd and Mosley are in the final undefeated

Tzsyu beats pac, oscar and hatton

Oscar beats Pac and Hatton

Paquaio beats Hatton, loses to everyone else

Hatton loses to everyone

Wow, we both agree on everything. As for Cotto, he'd lose to all due to his weak chin, possibly beating Hatton. Cotto vs Hatton can go either way.

[El Chicano]

I need another name to make it 8, if you all don't help me out I'm gonna through Amir or Victor in there

[UnDeniable]

Ooooo, let me redo it with Cotto in the mix!

But I need another 140 pounder to make it an even eight, help me out someone...

Do you mean recent or ever

Chavez was a great junior Welterweight

[WhoreUs]

mosley or oscar

[Sox8055]

Mayweather and Mosley

Mayweather wins it thought on his ability to adapt, be quicker, and box smarter.

[NakiFan]

Put JCC in there as number 8

[El Chicano]

Put JCC in there as number 8

Are you for real? The Meldrick Taylor version? The Roger Mayweather II version? That might not be fair...

[UnDeniable]

Did Shane even fight at 140

Replace him with Pryor, add JCC as #8 then you have 8 guys who fought at the weight

[aether]

im gonna go with shane. i think pac would do better than what most expects..

[El Chicano]

OK, put Cotto and Chavez in there. Chavez is as old school as I wanna get here.

Now, I got Shane vs a prime Chavez in the finals with 6-0 records each. I can't pick a winner

Oscar beats everyone except Shane and a prime Chavez

Floyd beats Tszyu, Manny, Ricky and Miguel

Manny beats Tszyu, Ricky & Miguel

Tszyu (prime) KOs Ricky & Miguel

Miguel edges Ricky