@ 140lbs, Who Comes Out On Top...

[El Chicano]

...In a Mythical Round Robin Tourney???

Julio Cesar Chavez - 1989-90 version

Oscar De La Hoya - 1st Chavez fight version

Shane Mosley - 1999, Pre-Oscar version

Manny Pacquiao - Current version

Floyd Mayweather - vs Arturo Gatti version

Miguel Cotto - vs Paulie Malignaggi version

Kostya Tszyu - Prime version

Ricky Hatton - vs Tszyu version

I got Shane and a prime JCC meeting each other for the Final with records of 7-0 each. Cant pick a winner. The Shane that fought Oscar was amazing. Granted that fight was at Welter, but I think he would've been even hotter at 140lbs. A prime Chavez was one of the best ever in the weight class.

[MANGLER]

SSM wins it.

[Manny Duckman]

Floyd with ease IMO

[F-22 Raptor]

i think SSM wins it with Pacquiao close second.

[UnDeniable]

Everyone would have lost at least once IMO

Hatton wouldn't have won a single fight

[UnDeniable]

BTW, i'm going with Floyd because hes the most adaptable

Would have been a classic tournament

[Doctor_Tenma]

Everyone would have lost at least once IMO

Hatton wouldn't have won a single fight

we all must admit, Hatton isn't winning a fight here.

[El Chicano]

Ooooo, let me redo it with Cotto in the mix!

But I need another 140 pounder to make it an even eight, help me out someone...

[Doctor_Tenma]

Tszyu > Pacquiao
Tszyu > Hatton
Tszyu and SSM would be very competitive, I see SSM winning a U.D though.
DLH > Everyone on list, except Mayweather, Shane.
Only see Pacquiao beating Hatton on that list. Believe Mayweather will come out on top.

[NakiFan]

Floyd and Mosley are in the final undefeated

Tzsyu beats pac, oscar and hatton

Oscar beats Pac and Hatton

Paquaio beats Hatton, loses to everyone else

Hatton loses to everyone