@ 140lbs, Who Comes Out On Top...

[Primal Instinx]

I have to go with Chavez

[nujabes77]

time for my favorite kostya highlight......

long live the king.

a beast indeed...

[Manny Duckman]

When was Kostya prime???

When he got KO'd by Phillips or when Hatton made his ass quit on a stool

[WhoreUs]

When was Kostya prime???

When he got KO'd by Phillips or when Hatton made his ass quit on a stool

learn a little bit more about boxing and you can figure it out for yourself.

welcome to the sport btw. we're always glad to hear about newcomers to the sport.

[Dambala]

Really hard to pick a winner here. JCC would've been outboxed by Floyd the same way Whitaker did it.

Final=Mayweather vs Oscar or Tszyu.

[WhoreUs]

and pac KTFO ricky in a judo match?

ssm is old, bhop is old...

again ask ricky hatton who hits harder

the old pac was prone to gettin hit with the right, tru

you should have seen the fight in england.......

it was disgusting how they let ricky grab and clinch and wrestle and hit and hold and hit on breaks.

not everyone ages the same.

kostya was 36 and had 2 fights the last 2 and half years.

he was always injured too that's why he had long layoffs.


young kostya would have beat hatton. he gave hatton a tough time even as old as he was and even with the hometown reffing.

[WhoreUs]

Floyd wins 7- 0 with 7 Ko's

but seriously, no 1 member from that group goes through the other 7 undefeated

floyd loses to everyone except hatton and cotto.

[baracuda]

pac or mosely...

[UnDeniable]

floyd loses to everyone except hatton and cotto.

Its possible

I aint gonna lie, Pac, Tszyu, Oscar, Mosley and JCC could have all beaten Floyd

Floyd on that night against Gatti was really motivated though, it was his first PPV fight and he had to make an impression

I'll never forget Gattis face in the corner after the fight, 2 swollen eyes, he was practically blind, his cheekbones were ****ed up, cuts all over his face...Floyd was disgustingly good that night

[tesla_power]

...In a Mythical Round Robin Tourney???

Julio Cesar Chavez - 1989-90 version

Oscar De La Hoya - 1st Chavez fight version

Shane Mosley - 1999, Pre-Oscar version

Manny Pacquiao - Current version

Floyd Mayweather - vs Arturo Gatti version

Miguel Cotto - vs Paulie Malignaggi version

Kostya Tszyu - Prime version

Ricky Hatton - vs Tszyu version

I got Shane and a prime JCC meeting each other for the Final with records of 7-0 each. Cant pick a winner. The Shane that fought Oscar was amazing. Granted that fight was at Welter, but I think he would've been even hotter at 140lbs. A prime Chavez was one of the best ever in the weight class.

prime Tszyu. I would never vote against him especially if he displays that superb performance in the Forrest fight. hehehe. As long as he does not immediately go looking for the KO or fall in love with his power, I would favor him against all others.