Hopkins has to be Top 10 ATG....Seriously.

[TredKiller]

Sugar Ray Robinson (GOAT)
Henry Armstrong (3 division titles at the same time)
Muhammad Ali (Greatest Resume in history)
Willie Pep (241-11)
Joe Louis (Most dominate HW in history)
George Foreman (hardest hitter, stacked resume)
Archie Moore (fought into his late 40's, longest reining LHW, most ko's)
Roberto Duran (greatest LW in history, going 75-1 in prime)
Sugar Ray Leonard (Stacked resume, only lost once in his prime)
Harry Greb (was koing HW's, only man to beat gene tunny)
Marvin Hagler (Very stacked resume, great accomplishments.)

these are just some fighters that rank higher then Bhop,
due to there accomplishments, resume, exc.

im a huge bhop fan to, i think he deffinatly ranks in
the top 30

[Burner]

Hopkins as usual picking on bloated lightweights/welterweights.

Tarver.

Pavlik.

Hmm since when did those guys weigh 147 pounds...

And Hopkins beat them past his prime...lol...while in his mid forties.

And gave Calzaghe all he could handle...

The ****??

[MANGLER]

Luv Bhop, but I dunno about top 10 all time.

[UnDeniable]

What era are we referring to? Roy was the fighter of the 90's...

Bernard has to compete with Floyd and Pac for this generation...

And there's no way he's ahead of Duran...

The past 20 years Hop has done more than Pac, Roy and Floyd

Floyd and Pac have arguably done more this decade

Roy done more in the 90's but Hop's longevity and consistency is unparalleled

Unless Pac or Floyd can clean out 147, Hop is the best of the past 20 years

[-EX-]

Bernard's resume doesn't hold up to those guys I mentioned...it just doesn't.

[Burner]

In no particular order:

Muhammed Ali
Sugar Ray Robinson
Roberto Duran
Henry Armstrong
Sugar Ray Leonard
Willy Pep
Marvin Hagler
Joe Louis
Roy Jones Jr.
Joe Frazier

That's 10 ahead of Hopkins for me, and there's more I would put as well. The guy has been a tough, crafty veteran who deserves credit for the incredible career he has had, but most his best wins are over smaller guys he was able to fight incredibly dirty against.

Roy Jone based on resume alone isnt a Top 10 ATG...


Hopkins has had the better career.....

[rizkybizness]

Tarver.

Pavlik.

Hmm since when did those guys weigh 147 pounds...

And Hopkins beat them past his prime...lol...while in his mid forties.

And gave Calzaghe all he could handle...

The ****??

you can only name 2 guys out of his entire resume

TOP 10 ATG FOR SUREEEEEEEEEEEEEE

[Sir Tom Jones]

got respect for him, but no way top 10.

[TheGreatA]

Hopkins never fought a guyw who weighed 147 pounds in the ring..PERIOD.

If a fighter wants to move up and challenge themselves dont blame Hopkins for waxing.

Hopkins moved up to remember and beat the **** out of the 175 Champion.

I don't blame Hopkins for it but I just can't rate De La Hoya as a legit win at 160. He struggled with Sturm who isn't all too good and actually gave Hopkins some problems until succumbing to Hopkins' strength and size.

Trinidad was a great win.

Beating Tarver is impressive but I've never seen Tarver as that great. Pavlik is another good fighter but hardly great.

[UnDeniable]

Don't get me wrong though, Prime Roy was a better fighter than Hop and i think Prime Floyd was a better fighter than Hop but Hop is definitely greater than both