Fernando Vargas or Miguel Cotto?

[eazy_mas]

Vargas

Tito and DHL are enough to shut out all of who Cotto fought.


As well as the risk of facing a champion very early in his career.

[Sin City]

Feroz.....wasnt a fan but he has a solid resume

true ****, I dont really like the guy but can't help but wonder what he could've been.
he got the worst of the worst managment team (Main Events) & that's what cost him his career..

[MANGLER]

Vargas fought better comp, but as noted by others Cotto won all but 1 of his big fights.

[LAkers85]

Hands down Fernando Vargas, but both Vargas and Cotto have something in common they fought 2 cheaters. i see two fighters that fought with loaded gloves and one fighter who used HGH .

[Steak]

Quartey and Wright were very solid wins...

Marquez and Castellejo were still around only about a year ago, too, despite being about 40. they were good fighters.
Campas was a good win back then too.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

people crap on him too much.

i hated the guy and loved tito and oscar cracking him but the guy fought top opponents.

people just forget the big wins he had when he was young because it was a long time ago.

the only time, besides the olympics, that i rooted for Oscar was against Vargas...and yea Vargas' list is up there

[WhoreUs]

And the difference between them is when Cotto stepped up he won. And lets not get into debate about that bull**** Margarito fight because no one knows if that **** was packing or not. I believe he was but lets just leave that fight out of the picture for now.

?

when vargas stepped up?

tito and oscar stepped up to him.

he was the champ and they were the newcomers to the division.

vargas won his belt at 154 and #1 at 154 when tito and oscar was at 147.

they stepped up to him and won.

when did you start following boxing?

[Owlzfan84]

didnt read the question till after i voted. So i voted based on what i saw in the thread title. I think Miguel is a better fighter who has beaten better fighters overall, but Vargas fought the tougher competition.

[ACHlLLES]

Quartey and Wright were very solid wins.

Did he even beat Wright? I heard Wright was robbed, I never seen the fight though... If it was a close fight then I personally don't consider it a robbery, I thought I just seen a few Wright fans on here claiming Wright was robbed.

[baCCaT]

cotto hater