Hatton Comeback Talk Continues, Against Amir Khan?

[mmayer1981]

Don't be daft, I wasn't comparing anyone with anyone, do you always take analogies completely literally? I was pointing out that if any shot fighter loses to any more lowly rated fighter, it says absolutely nothing about how elite or otherwise they were when they were at their peak, and that even some of the greatest fighters in history have lost to nobodies after they were shot. And therefore for you to say that if a shot version of Hatton loses to Khan that proves anything about how good or otherwise he was when he was at his peak is ridiculous.

Dave, you are correct

[MELLY-MEL...]

Hatton needs to EARN a shot at Khan lmao

your a fucking moron, and this may be the dumbest post i have seen here. fuckin clown.

[gingeralbino]

what has khan done that people think he could beat Hatton? Hatton's beat a lot of fighters that are better than Khan is at this stage. Ricky by KO before the 5th starts. Khan doesnt have much pop anyway.

[BMWM3P]

Don't be daft, I wasn't comparing anyone with anyone, do you always take analogies completely literally? I was pointing out, using an analogy, that if any shot fighter loses to any more lowly rated fighter, it says absolutely nothing about how elite or otherwise they were when they were at their peak, and that even some of the greatest fighters in history have lost to nobodies after they were shot. And therefore for you to say that if a shot version of Hatton loses to Khan that proves anything about how good or otherwise he was when he was at his peak is ridiculous.

Your analogy is a horrible one, Ali and Hatton don't belong in the same sentenced. Like I said Ali is an acomplished fighter, Hatton far from it. If you had a used a much lowly fighter your analogie might have hit home.

Why do you use the term shor so *******y. Hatton is not a shot fighter, he's not an old fighter, he's just not that good. He been riding a masive hype wave from the Tszyu and it's just now dying down. If he's beat by glass jaw Kahn it'll tell you just that the he just wasn't the good.

The "old semi retired Tszyu" was rated #3 P4P at the time Hatton beat him and was coming off a FOTY win. The "shot overweight Castillo" was rated #9 P4P at the time Hatton beat him. He also beat almost all of the other top contenders in his weight class, over a period of nearly four years. Your definition of elite is not the dictionary definition. Elite doesn't mean ATG, it just means one of the top fighters in his weight class, and he was.

Tszyu was just ranked off of his previous work and I doubt Castillo was ranked number 9 at that time. He was coming off of the weight debacle with Corrales and he hadn't looked that good in his previous fights at 140. your definition of elite is misleading, an elite fighter is just not a top ranked fighter, it means an acomplished proven fighter something that Hatton never qualified for.

[Kevin Jesus]

Tszyu was just ranked off of his previous work and I doubt Castillo was ranked number 9 at that time. He was coming off of the weight debacle with Corrales and he hadn't looked that good in his previous fights at 140. your definition of elite is misleading, an elite fighter is just not a top ranked fighter, it means an acomplished proven fighter something that Hatton never qualified for.

What an idiot, you don't ever know what you are talking about do you?

Do you know what an analogy is? you're are a moron and a sad excuse for human like many of your other friends.

Let me ask you a question, don't take it personal. How old were you when you dropped out of Junior High School?

[HattonFaithful]

Tszyu was just ranked off of his previous work and I doubt Castillo was ranked number 9 at that time. He was coming off of the weight debacle with Corrales and he hadn't looked that good in his previous fights at 140. your definition of elite is misleading, an elite fighter is just not a top ranked fighter, it means an acomplished proven fighter something that Hatton never qualified for.

hahahaha something he never qualified for? are you serious so i guess ruling supreme at light welterweight for many years and winning titles in two different weight classes and the only two losses of his carreer coming to the best in the world at the time...ya youre right thats not elite at all

[THE NAMELESS]

God blass you,hatton.

[alza1988]

We aint even seen Khan box at 140 yet so I can't tell .Getting trained off Roach we've seen Pacquiao take power up in weight classes so there's a chance Khan can do the same.

[Phatfarm1980]

Khan will have more power at 140lbs and he has speed. Hatton struggles against guys with speed!

[JuanDan]

We aint even seen Khan box at 140 yet so I can't tell .Getting trained off Roach we've seen Pacquiao take power up in weight classes so there's a chance Khan can do the same.

Khan moved from Lightweight to light welterweight for a single fight against French fighter Rachid Drilzane on 9 December 2006, winning a 10 round decision. Khan experienced the first knockdown of his career when his opponent caught him with a good left. Drilzane had never scored a knockout in his 13 fight career. Khan returned to the lightweight division for future fights.