What's more acceptable? Manny vs Cotto @ 145 OR Floyd vs JMM @ 144?

[blind4]

manny vs Cotto @ 145lbs

[Luis12]

**** catchweights on the whole. I don't like either fight. But Pac jumpin 1 division looks better than JMM jumpin 2 divisions.

agreed.

JMM have a hard time against Diaz at 135...facing FMM at 144 it's a suicide

[#1Assassin]

floyd vs JMM obviously..

first of it was JMM who called out floyd, and floyd said fight me at a catchweight. now pacquiao came knocking on cottos door expecting him to drop, thats more messed up IMO. id much rather put on some muscles and fight a bigger guy, than kill myself to make a weight i shouldnt be making to fight a little guy who called ME out. eighter come to cottos ****ing weight or stay were the **** u are at. JMM called floyd out, floyd made him an offer and JMM took it, not as bad IMO as pac being a complete punk.

[AssasinKing]

floyd vs JMM obviously..

first of it was JMM who called out floyd, and floyd said fight me at a catchweight. now pacquiao came knocking on cottos door expecting him to drop, thats more messed up IMO. id much rather put on some muscles and fight a bigger guy, than kill myself to make a weight i shouldnt be making to fight a little guy who called ME out. eighter come to cottos ****ing weight or stay were the **** u are at. JMM called floyd out, floyd made him an offer and JMM took it, not as bad IMO as pac being a complete punk.

First time i gota disagree wiv u bud!

Cotto weighed in at 146 for the clottey fight....how is he going to kill himself to make 145? even 144 wouldnt be to bad from there....JMM is moving up 2 weight divisions, and im sure cotto wants the pac fight just as much as pac wants cotto....

[#1Assassin]

First time i gota disagree wiv u bud!

Cotto weighed in at 146 for the clottey fight....how is he going to kill himself to make 145? even 144 wouldnt be to bad from there....JMM is moving up 2 weight divisions, and im sure cotto wants the pac fight just as much as pac wants cotto....

the weight in itself. yes. but im more thinking about the challenge.

JMM calls out floyd, its not floyds fault JMM is a LW. JMM wants floyd he needs to go to floyd. pac called out cotto and then asked him to come down, u dont call nonody out and ask demands. thats like u want to fight someone in the streets and u call someone out to come to your block, u dont do that. u want someone u go to them. JMM was willing to come to floyd. pac should come to cotto or shut his mouth. he wants a 147lber, go to 147lbs. dont say i want u at this weight.. thats BS. JMM didnt ask floyd to come down, he was amn and went to floyd. thats what u do if u call someone out.

[AssasinKing]

the weight in itself. yes. but im more thinking about the challenge.

JMM calls out floyd, its not floyds fault JMM is a LW. JMM wants floyd he needs to go to floyd. pac called out cotto and then asked him to come down, u dont call nonody out and ask demands. thats like u want to fight someone in the streets and u call someone out to come to your block, u dont do that. u want someone u go to them. JMM was willing to come to floyd. pac should come to cotto or shut his mouth. he wants a 147lber, go to 147lbs. dont say i want u at this weight.. thats BS. JMM didnt ask floyd to come down, he was amn and went to floyd. thats what u do if u call someone out.

The thing is, when your #1, your not REALLY calling people out, its more like, giving the top contender a chance....Im sure if manny did nothing for a few weeks...he would of had cotto knocking at his door asking him to fight him, willing to make sacrifices....And if pac should go to cotto, why would cotto be happy to negotiate a weight if he isnt happy with it? The only reason fighters end up draining themselves is through bad calculating and also trying to max the size they are gonna come into the ring....cotto can drop 1-2 pounds easy, im sure he aint got a problem with that, cos if he did he doesnt seem the type to go into a fight to disappoint his fans

And dont forget this is still a weight ABOVE pacmans weight...where as floyd is at his natural weight and yet claims to be the better fighter...in order for a fight to be even you both gota make compromises, pac going up from 140 where he seemed perfect for the weight....goin up by 4-5 pounds...and cotto dropping 1-2 pounds...

[Allucard]

Obviously Cotto V Manny.
Think logically, JMM is a natural Super Featherweight/Lightweight. FMJ has fought at Jr. Middleweight before, so this gives him a huge advantage of a naturally smaller man. Although JMM is P4P better than anyone FMJ has ever faced, he is a lot smaller than anyone FMJ has ever fought at Welterweight and so has virtually no chance of winning.
Manny has fought at 147 before, albeit against a shot DLH, but at least he has done it. He's a natural LWW - but he should be able to move up a weight if he fought DLH at that weight (one of the best of his generation) then he should fight Cotto at that weight, especially if it's for the belt. However, it is a bit fairer on Pacquiao, and Cotto is only giving away about a pound as he weighed in around 146 for the Clottey fight. But it's likely to be 144, which Cotto should still make comfortably.

Fought at middleweight???? LOL 154 isn't middleweight you ***** and Floyd weighed in 147, hydrated to 149 fight night. He NEVER FOUGHT AT MIDDLEWEIGHT TACO EATING WHORE god that felt good. Now go back to eating tacos or prison or whatever the hell u came out from.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

**** Catchweights

[#1Assassin]

**** Catchweights

AGREED! **** both ****ing fights.

[The Surgeon]

**** catchweights on the whole. I don't like either fight. But Pac jumpin 1 division looks better than JMM jumpin 2 divisions.

Im wit u Mangler! Theres not enough divisions already!?? **** em! Either move up or dont who gives a ****!

And yeah Cotto vs Pac is better as its only 1 division apart but it still blows IMO