Cotto vs Clottey Scorecards post yours

[BOOMbip]

Off hand I can't think of a time I have either. But this is an interesting case.




Of course. :-) It's the differences in opinion, and what we value in scoring a round, that make this sport fun.

I feel how you feel!

[street bully]

................first watch.................................................. ....second watch

Round 1 Cotto 10 Clottey 8..................................Cotto 10 Clottey 8

Round 2 Cotto 9 Clottey 10 ................................Cotto 9..Clottey 10

Round 3 ..Cotto 10 Clottey 9................................Cotto 10 Clottey 9

Round 4 Cotto 9 .Clottey 10................................Cotto 9...Clottey 10

Round 5 Cotto 9....Clottey 10................................Cotto 9 Clottey 10

Round 6 Cotto 10 Clottey 9................................. Cotto 10 Clottey 9

Round 7 Cotto 9 Clottey 10....................... Cotto 9.. Clottey 10

Round 8 Cotto 9.Clottey 10....................... Cotto 9..Clottey 10

Round 9 Cotto 9 Clottey 10....................... Cotto 9 .Clottey 10

Round 10 Cotto 10 Clottey ....changed.......Cotto 9 Clottey 10

Round 11 Cotto 10 Clottey 9..................................Cotto 10 Clottey 9

Round 12 Cotto 10 Clottey 9.......................Cotto 10 Clottey 9


............ 114 -114.....................................Clottey 114 -113

Good score card. Clottey won that fight.

[oc9979]

I had Clottey winning 10-9 until the knockdown. To go from 10-9 Clottey to 10-8 Cotto is a three point turnaround. I could see that if Clottey was flattened and truly hurt. But not all knockdowns are the same. This particular knockdown - IMO - doesn't call for a 10-8 Cotto round.

so you scored the round even before it was over?

[STEELHEAD]

................first watch.................................................. ....second watch

Round 1 Cotto 10 Clottey 8..................................Cotto 10 Clottey 8

Round 2 Cotto 9 Clottey 10 ................................Cotto 9..Clottey 10

Round 3 ..Cotto 10 Clottey 9................................Cotto 10 Clottey 9

Round 4 Cotto 9 .Clottey 10................................Cotto 9...Clottey 10

Round 5 Cotto 9....Clottey 10................................Cotto 9 Clottey 10

Round 6 Cotto 10 Clottey 9................................. Cotto 10 Clottey 9

Round 7 Cotto 9 Clottey 10....................... Cotto 9.. Clottey 10

Round 8 Cotto 9.Clottey 10....................... Cotto 9..Clottey 10

Round 9 Cotto 9 Clottey 10....................... Cotto 9 .Clottey 10

Round10Cotto 10 Clottey10 ....changed.......Cotto 9 Clottey 10

Round 11 Cotto 10 Clottey 9..................................Cotto 10 Clottey 9

Round 12 Cotto 10 Clottey 9.......................Cotto 10 Clottey 9


............ 114 -114.....................................Clottey 114 -113

clottey gave cotto the last two rounds!
but cotto is back!

no mention of clottey being pissed when no point deduction when cotto lowblowed or when cotto smacked him in the back of the head or when cotto thru him down.
or the specialy made boots cotto was sporting that didnt slip and slide like clotteys did on freshly painted ring canvas.

[BOOMbip]

Just watched the fight for a thrid time and have it again.

Round 1:Cotto 10-8

Round 2:Clottey 10-9

Round 3:Cotto 10-9

Round 4:Cotto 10-9

Round 5:Clottey 10-9

Round 6:Cotto 10-9

Round 7:Clottey 10-9

Round 8:Clottey 10-9

Round 9:Clottey 10-9

Round 10:Clottey 10-9

Round 11:Cotto 10-9

Round 12 Cotto 10-9


114-113 Cotto

and that's how I had it when I watched live at MSG

Completely unbiased and objective.

[savorduhflavor]

Just watched the fight for a thrid time and have it again.

Round 1:Cotto 10-8

Round 2:Clottey 10-9

Round 3:Cotto 10-9

Round 4:Cotto 10-9

Round 5:Clottey 10-9

Round 6:Cotto 10-9

Round 7:Clottey 10-9

Round 8:Clottey 10-9

Round 9:Clottey 10-9

Round 10:Clottey 10-9

Round 11:Cotto 10-9

Round 12 Cotto 10-9


114-113 Cotto

and that's how I had it when I watched live at MSG

Completely unbiased and objective.

After watching it 6 times, that's the same exact scorecard I have.

[Knicksman20]

1st - 10-8 Cotto Even though I thought Clottey had won the round till the KD.
2nd - 10-9 Clottey
3rd - 10-9 Cotto
4th - 10-9 Clottey
5th - 10-9 Clottey
6th - 10-9 Cotto
7th-11th Clottey
12th - 10-9 Cotto

115-112 Clottey

[BOOMbip]

1st - 10-8 Cotto Even though I thought Clottey had won the round till the KD.
2nd - 10-9 Clottey
3rd - 10-9 Cotto
4th - 10-9 Clottey
5th - 10-9 Clottey
6th - 10-9 Cotto
7th-11th Clottey
12th - 10-9 Cotto

115-112 Clottey

I gave the 4th and 11th to Cotto making it 114-113 Cotto.

[Knicksman20]

I gave the 4th and 11th to Cotto making it 114-113 Cotto.

I thought the 11th was closer than the 4th but I still gave it to Clottey. He pressed the action & landed the harder punches while Cotto was backing up trying to shoeshine.

[SonOfCuba]

Clottey by 1