Is JMM an ATG??? Yes or No

[MaD RoBoT]

JMM has a nice resume, and has never really lost a fight if you closely study his losses.

2 losses over Pacquiao
Barrera????
KO'd "Older than DLH-robbed/lost to SantaCruz(who lost to DAVID DIAZ)"Casamayor
KO'd "Overrated-schooled by Grandpa Nate" J.Diaz

Fixed it for ya

[Cadillac Man]

JMM is the best fighter out Mexico since Chavez...Yes he is an ATG HANDS DOWN!

[sandyvahra]

HOF yes, ATG no

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

No aint, his 2 best wins are a loss and a draw to pacquiao. The the diaz fight, Casamayor and barrera, he needs to beat to other Hofers to be consider one.

He will be definetly if he somehow, pull something out of his ass and beats FLoyd!!!!!!!!!1

[Cadillac Man]

How could say JMM is not an ATG? He beat Barrera, KO'd a HOF in Casa who had never been KO'd before, beat a prime former lightweight kingpin who had nvr been KO'd before in DIaz, Gave an ATG in Pac his toughest fights to date, nvr really lost a fight in heavily disputed losses to Norwood,Pac and John in Indonesia. If u say JMM is not an ATG u eithier a hater or don't know Boxing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Pullcounter]

How could say JMM is not an ATG? He beat Barrera, KO'd a HOF in Casa who had never been KO'd before, beat a prime former lightweight kingpin who had nvr been KO'd before in DIaz, Gave an ATG in Pac his toughest fights to date, nvr really lost a fight in heavily disputed losses to Norwood,Pac and John in Indonesia. If u say JMM is not an ATG u eithier a hater or don't know Boxing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i guess you can call JMM an ATG, but he'd be in the 100s or something. I mean boxing has a long history of ATG fighters.

[Cadillac Man]

i guess you can call JMM an ATG, but he'd be in the 100s or something. I mean boxing has a long history of ATG fighters.

Don't know where he'd be number wise but technically he the best out of Mexico since Sal Sanchez. Overall the best out of boxing rich Mexico since J.C. Chavez.

[Hagler★]

casamayor is an atg and jmm knocked him out, only fighter to ever do so might i add. add that to beating barerra, pacquiao twice and winning titles at 3 diffrent weights and u have yourself a atg

Simplified version of this thread

[andrew14]

if he won against PBF and pac. he WILL.

GREAT= PBF and PAC

if not. fighting only and losing to someone great is not a legitimate reason.

winning against barrera, casa, diaz and losing too chris john is not quite

convincing.

[boojee]

NO. old and shot barrera beat him, Pac beat him twice. he beat an old and shot casamayor. he was beaten by Chris John. so NO he is not an atg.