Who do you rate higher CURRENTLY P4P?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Winky is a better fighter than Shane Mosley. Mosley is the only top fighter Cotto beat, and that fight could have gone either way. Lets not forget Winky completely undressed Mosley.

Complete Nonsense, Styles makes fight, Who is a overall better Fight Mosley or Winky?

If you think Cotto-Mosley could of gne either way, you dont know **** about scoring a fight!!!!!!!!!!!

Williams resume
Margarito
Winky
Quintana x2
Phillips
Mitchell

Cottos resume
Molsey
QUintana
Judah
Malignaggi
Torres
Corley
Bailley
Maussa
Ndou

Can yoy see the difference now??
Bazan
ABdullaev

[Iceta]

I would have to go with P-Dub. He gutted it out against Margarito and Cotto was beaten into submission by Antonio plaster or no plaster. Williams also beat Winky like an abused housewife while I had Mosley beating Cotto due to the superiority in power punches and aggressiveness at the end of their fight. The only way this favors Cotto is their respective rivalries with Quintana. And it's a weak case for Cotto because Williams was competitive in their first fight and came back and did what a champion is supposed to do like Joe Louis did with Max Schmelling.

[street bully]

Complete Nonsense, Styles makes fight, Who is a overall better Fight Mosley or Winky?

If you think Cotto-Mosley could of gne either way, you dont know **** about scoring a fight!!!!!!!!!!!

Williams resume
Margarito
Winky
Quintana x2
Phillips
Mitchell

Cottos resume
Molsey
QUintana
Judah
Malignaggi
Torres
Corley
Bailley
Maussa
Ndou

Can yoy see the difference now??
Bazan
ABdullaev

Yes I think Wright is an overall better fighter than Mosley you think Mosley could **** with Taylor and beat him and have a close fight with Hopkins. And in all honesty the fight with Cotto and Mosley was damn close and I had it a draw, and almost everyone acknowledges that it was a close fight.

[savorduhflavor]

I can buy Williams being higher than Cotto right now.

If Cotto beats Clottey impressively, I might have to put Cotto back up over him, but it could go either way.

[street bully]

I can buy Williams being higher than Cotto right now.

If Cotto beats Clottey impressively, I might have to put Cotto back up over him, but it could go either way.

Co-sign if Cotto mops the floor with Clottey like Williams did to Winky then he should be rated a little higher.

[Bushbaby]

It's real simple,while Cotto isnt the best in his division,The Punisher is the best in Cotto's division and at 154 and 160,so that pretty much speaks for itself!!

[Iceta]

Co-sign if Cotto mops the floor with Clottey like Williams did to Winky then he should be rated a little higher.

I would have to respectfully disagree. Clottey's wins over Zab and Chico are decent but they don't match up to Winky's wins over Mosley twice, Quartey, Trinidad, the disputable draw to Jermaine Taylor, and a loss to B-Hop of where he didn't disgrace himself. I am not a fan of Winky because of his defensive style and I'm saying all these good things about him. Ha Ha Ha Ha. But hey, respect is due where it's due, and the Winkster's resume is nothing to sneeze at. And Clottey is coming off a long layoff too even if it's not as long as the layoff that Winky went through.