Rank these six welterweights

[steptwome]

1. Mayweather
2. Mosley
3. Cotto
4. Margarito, Clottey
5. Berto

[street bully]

Who would beat who? That's how I ranked them.

If it's who would beat who why isn't Margarito ahead of Cotto?

[daggum]

any of the fighter you mentioned would beat bladomir
clottey was beating him in all the judges card

but baldomir was the lineal champ! and if i've learned anything about boxing that means you can beat anyone anytime anywhere.

[Jabrony]

Mr boat buyer
SSM
Cotto
Clottey
Berto

I based this on who would win the most against the rest. I left Marg out cuz he's outta the picture right now. In terms of actual rank it's the same but Mr boat buyer ain't in it.

If that is the case why do you have Mosley over Cotto? Cotto beat him by UD if you don't remember and gave Sugar Shane a boxing clinic.

[daggum]

If that is the case why do you have Mosley over Cotto? Cotto beat him by UD if you don't remember and gave Sugar Shane a boxing clinic.

when was the boxing clinic though? you wouldn't be exaggerating a razor close fight would you?

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Alot of Cotto nut huggerz on these boards

Mosley
Cotto
Clott
Berto
Margo

IF Cotto wins over Clottey he can probably have a pretty good case for first place, atm he ain't done **** after the bad beating Margo gave him. While some people will say he beat Mosley so he should be above him, well Mosley vs Cotto =close fight, with Mosley not at his best. Then Margo destroys Cotto, Mosley Destroys Margo, pretty obvious who should be top for the moment.

Mayweather dont make me laugh great fighter but should not be mentioned as a WW untill he faces 2 or 3 of these 5 guys. Margo dropped to bottom due to his cheating and year of inactivity.

[Jabrony]

when was the boxing clinic though? you wouldn't be exaggerating a razor close fight would you?

Stop exaggerating dude the fight was not razor close and watch that fight again Cotto out box and out worked Mosley the whole fight.

[Horus]

WELTERWEIGHT DIVISION

Lineal Champion: Vacant
Previous Lineal Champion: Floyd Mayweather
Champion Emeritus: Floyd Mayweather (Welterweight and JuniorMiddleweight)


1. Shane Mosley
2. Paul Williams
3. Miguel Cotto
4. Joshua Clottey
5. Andre Berto

[Jabrony]

Alot of Cotto nut huggerz on these boards

Mosley
Cotto
Clott
Berto
Margo

IF Cotto wins over Clottey he can probably have a pretty good case for first place, atm he ain't done **** after the bad beating Margo gave him. While some people will say he beat Mosley so he should be above him, well Mosley vs Cotto =close fight, with Mosley not at his best. Then Margo destroys Cotto, Mosley Destroys Margo, pretty obvious who should be top for the moment.

Mayweather dont make me laugh great fighter but should not be mentioned as a WW untill he faces 2 or 3 of these 5 guys. Margo dropped to bottom due to his cheating and year of inactivity.

Mosley not at his best? What a bunch of excuses by some of you. Is pretty amazing how delusional some of you can be.....Pathetic.

[sylvestersweet]

If it's who would beat who why isn't Margarito ahead of Cotto?

Plaster......