Rank these six welterweights

[steptwome]

1. Mayweather,
2. Mosley,
3. Cotto
4. Margarito, Clottey (tied)
5. Berto

[Spacey1991]

I don't understand how Mayweather gets number 1 in these lists..yet he's never fought a WW..LMAO!..ahh ****Ryderz..gotta love em!..

We can't rank him until he has a fight... that's if your talking about now, if the TS is saying how do you rank these fighters at WW right now... we can't put Floyd up there because he hasn't had his first fight back from his comeback yet.

If we are meant to be ranking them in terms of talent alone (like the P4P rankings), then I guess I could understand them putting him first, you get what I mean?

[ILLuminato]

This is your problem as a poster and quite likely as a human being, too: Everything is black and white. You are not here to debate. You just make statements and stand by them like an obstinate 2 year old who wants an ice cream cone.

How can you possibly have Mayweather at #1 in terms of ranking based on achievement???? It's not like he even has a championship belt. To be honest you can't even put him on a ranking list. If the Patriots stopped playing for a year would you put them first on a ranking list? No.

[The_Demon]

We can't rank him until he has a fight... that's if your talking about now, if the TS is saying how do you rank these fighters at WW right now... we can't put Floyd up there because he hasn't had his first fight back from his comeback yet.

If we are meant to be ranking them in terms of talent alone (like the P4P rankings), then I guess I could understand them putting him first, you get what I mean?

ye thats wot i mean its a matter of opinion,i think mayweather would beat the other guys on the list so id have him at 1-plenty of people on here will disagree though

[Little Mac]

Cotto
Clottey
Mosley
Mayweather
Berto
------------
Margarito

[boxasmash]

1. Mayweather,
2. Mosley,
3. Cotto
4. Margarito, Clottey (tied)
5. Berto

how is mayweather #1?

that goes out to everyone who said he was too.

[daggum]

lets see how many times the top 5 have fought each other

cotto-fought mosley,margarito and is fighting clottey

clottey-fought margarito and is fighting cotto

margarito-fought cotto, clottey, and mosley

mosley-fought margarito and cotto

mayweather-fought none of them but hey he beat baldomir who was the lineal champ so that trumps them all!

[oc9979]

Talent Wise.

Mayweather
Cotto
Mosley
Clottey
Berto
Margarito

Ranking wise

Cotto
Mosley
Clottey
Margarito
Berto
>
>
>
>
Floyd!

this is the way i see it.

[..WaRSpencE..]

lets see how many times the top 5 have fought each other

cotto-fought mosley,margarito and is fighting clottey

clottey-fought margarito and is fighting cotto

margarito-fought cotto, clottey, and mosley

mosley-fought margarito and cotto

mayweather-fought none of them but hey he beat baldomir who was the lineal champ so that trumps them all!

You forgot Sharmba Mitchell and Ricky Hatton!..oh wait..those were overblown Jr Welterweights!..oopz!

[oc9979]

lets see how many times the top 5 have fought each other

cotto-fought mosley,margarito and is fighting clottey

clottey-fought margarito and is fighting cotto

margarito-fought cotto, clottey, and mosley

mosley-fought margarito and cotto

mayweather-fought none of them but hey he beat baldomir who was the lineal champ so that trumps them all!

any of the fighter you mentioned would beat bladomir
clottey was beating him in all the judges card