Is Cotto a ***** if he fights Pac at 144?

[Xcusemymood]

I think it is, but you know. We will have to agree to disagree.

Anyways, what should happend after this fight(Becauise is añready sign) is Cotto-Pacquiao, Mosley-Floyd winners meet in the end!!!!!!!!!!!

What should happen is JMM-PBF winner gets Pac winner of that fights the winner of Mosley-Cotto 2.

Makes more sense because winner PBF/PaC/JMM= P4P no.1

Mosley-Cotto have unfinished biz.

[RodBarker]

hatton and judah are no comparison to margs mosley and clottey

Thats right , they are smaller a lot smaller ,,,,, Floyd steps into the ring at 147 ,,,,, Cotto 160 and Mosley 160 ,,,,,, is it so ***en hard to figure Floyd is really a Jnr W fighting much bigger fighters ,, Jones won a HW title is he a ***en HW lots go up and win a tiltle dont mean thats why they are naturally ,,,, why is that every other guy that goes up is little but not Floyd who is expected to give huge weight away fight after fight , and then the fools cry Floyd cant KO them and runs ,,,,,,, dimwits on this board by the 100s .

What they step into the ring at is their true size as a fighter , not dried out prune weight the day before ,, the trainers know it the fighters know it , thats why they want catchweights to even the size difference up , its not rocket science boys and the weights are all well recorded and mentioned for all to see and hear .


Pac steps in at 147
Floyd at 147-8
JMM at 144
Cotto 160
Mosley 160
Hatton 152
Williams 162
Margo 160
Casa 146
Diaz 145

[larry x]

I think it is, but you know. We will have to agree to disagree.

Anyways, what should happend after this fight(Becauise is añready sign) is Cotto-Pacquiao, Mosley-Floyd winners meet in the end!!!!!!!!!!!

that makes no sense..cotto should fight mosley since they both hold titles at 147..floyd has no belt and isnt even obligated to a weight class right now..floyd-pacman.cotto-mosley

[DGP]

he is cosidered to be the welter champ if those guys are too big go down in weight. if you make the weight you can fight in that division simple as that

[RodBarker]

he is cosidered to be the welter champ if those guys are too big go down in weight. if you make the weight you can fight in that division simple as that

Just like Pac and Hatton and Juan , can all weigh-in under 147 and over 140 , does that make them true WWs or a very small guy in with a big guy when against true WWs ,,, Floyd weighed 150 for a 154 weigh-in and then stepped into the ring at 148 while Oscar went to 160 ,,, is Floyd a JM ,,,, weigh-in weight is bull**** weight manipulated to allow somebody to fight in a division so low they could never actually fight in it ,,,, real weight is fight weight on the night when they fight .

[DGP]

thats the way the rules are if you can make the weight you fight at that weight class. also if your truly too big for that weight class you will hurt your body trying to make that weight.

[Pugilistic™]

Cotto fighting Pacquiao at 144 is not the same as Mayweather fighting Marquez at 144.

The difference is Cotto will struggle to make 144 and the chances are will be drained at the weight.

Mayweather will make 144 with ease, He could likely make 140 if he wanted so he isn't really giving Marquez any advantage at all where Cotto going to 144 is giving Pacquiao a big advantage.

[DGP]

do you suggest more weight classes

[RodBarker]

do you suggest more weight classes

How about fighters just fight under the weight class limit as it was ment to be , instead of 160 lb fighters weigh-in a day before dehydrated to make the class they could never fight in in a million years , fine if they gunna fight at the weigh-in but they dont ,,,,, what we have is a case of trying to help the safety aspects of boxing by not fighting dehydrated but then sports science comes along and abuses the system to create advantages for some ,,, if you are a WW fight at between 147-140 , thats the meaning of the weight classes .

I know the rules but in a dedicated boxing forum you guys are supposed to know how they are being manipulated to favor some and handicap others ,,, but you dont and if you did you would look at fighters under a different light .

[this is nove]

Why would cotto be a ***** if he fought pacquiao. Lol doesnt everybody wanna fight pac.