J.L.Castillo is he ATG as lightweight??

[LA BAD BOY]

In my opinion he beat Floyd Mayweather,and he was
biggest and strongest lightweight ever.
Is he ATG as lightweight?

[Leatherface]

I think you definetly have to consider him for it.

[WhoreUs]

no.

very good fighter and possibly even a HOFer down the line but not a great nor all time great.

[Mary Jane]

Yup, Johnston, Bazan, Lazcano, Casamayor, Julio Diaz, and Corrales are great wins. He was in that war with Corrales. He had a close fight with Mayweather. Won the WBC belt twice, defended it 5 times.

[Mary Jane]

no.

very good fighter and possibly even a HOFer down the line but not a great nor all time great.

Maybe not overall, but at that weight, he was a monster. His only negative at 135 were his two losses to Mayweather, but you can't dig at anyone for that, plus the first fight was really close. I actually had it for Castillo, 7-5.

[MANGLER]

no.

very good fighter and possibly even a HOFer down the line but not a great nor all time great.

Co-sign homey.

[WhoreUs]

Maybe not overall, but at that weight, he was a monster. His only negative at 135 were his two losses to Mayweather, but you can't dig at anyone for that, plus the first fight was really close. I actually had it for Castillo, 7-5.

he's definitely a very good fighter but i don't know about atg.

plus wasn't floyd injured in the 1st fight?

[Obama]

I think he's a top 20 Lightweight. And I think that puts him in line to be one of the 250 greatest fighters of all time...

And for the record, there have been hall of famers I wouldn't rate in the top 500.

[Pullcounter]

In my opinion he beat Floyd Mayweather,and he was
biggest and strongest lightweight ever.
Is he ATG as lightweight?

HOFer? Yes.

ATG? No.

[-EX-]

He has a pretty good resume at 135 but not great, and deff not all time great. I don't believe he beat Floyd either.