The definitive poll: Who's higher on the ATG list--Calzaghe or Hopkins?

[hookoutofhell]

Trinidad and DLH didn't have a chance? Idk bout that...

Trinidad had won at 160 before he met Bernard...

hed never convinced at that weight though - by the time he got to 160 he was done as a fighter and boxing men who were simply too big for him

he had no buisness above 154

[ACHlLLES]

I'd give it to Hopkins but not by a huge margin like the racists on here will say.

[Run]

Jones is a china chin, That puts him below Hopkins.

lolwut ?

Jones is one of the greatest P4P fighters of all time.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

[robjr]

anyone who actually picks calzaghe here is just being biased and know that Hopkins easily passes him as an ATG.. Or you completely lack boxing knowledge..

[S.G.]

"P4P" don't mean **** to me... it's just fat balding journalists making **** up. "Yeah, Hopkins could beat any fighter if they were the same size... but he's not, so here's another barn burner with Robert Allen."

Hopkins would get ****d by Hagler.

well i was more just noting that he's been considered to be amongst the very best for 10(+) years

which is an impressive feat...

[Patheticfraud?]

Hopkins is higher, though Hopkins gets overated by a lot of people. His best/most of his wins are from smaller guys who come up in weight to fight him who don't have a fair chance. (De La Hoya, Trinidad, Winky Wright etc.)

****** argument. That's like saying Pac doesn't have a fair chance. Gay excuse. Lots of guys are successful moving up.

[savorduhflavor]

It's Hopkins and it's not remotely debatable.

[hookoutofhell]

****** argument. That's like saying Pac doesn't have a fair chance. Gay excuse. Lots of guys are successful moving up.

what a dumbass, lots of guys are able to move up and lots of guys aren't.

some fighters aren't meant to be in certain weight classes - AA, mora dont belong at 160, SSM/mayweather doesn't belong at 154, DLH didn't belong at 160, neither did tito, winky/kelly had no buisness at 170....

in fact **** it, can't be arsed going over the same ole **** again

[bsrizpac]

hed never convinced at that weight though - by the time he got to 160 he was done as a fighter and boxing men who were simply too big for him

he had no buisness above 154

Uh really? Pretty sure he BROKE WILLIAM JOPPYS face in a horrific knockout. What was that? In another reality?

[-Swizzy-]

hahahahahahahaha, this is a joke right? hopkins and calzaghe are probably 100 spots apart in an all-time list. lol.