The definitive poll: Who's higher on the ATG list--Calzaghe or Hopkins?

[boxasmash]

Stunning logic.


Let's employ the logic of this genius Joe fan above:

Tevor Berbick greater than Ali.


see what I did there?

.................

[Zmlacksz]

Hopkins lost every big fight he was in (Jones, Calzaghe, Taylor). Yeah that makes him an all time great. Getting dropped twice by that bum Mercado and then getting gifted a draw decision when he lost that fight. If he fought in title fights outside of America more than once he would have lost more.
Hail Hopkins the all time great who looked good fighting blown up welterweights.

[-EX-]

What is this a joke? Bernard's resume is way better than Calzaghe's.

[bsrizpac]

Hopkins lost every big fight he was in (Jones, Calzaghe, Taylor). Yeah that makes him an all time great. Getting dropped twice by that bum Mercado and then getting gifted a draw decision when he lost that fight. If he fought in title fights outside of America more than once he would have lost more.
Hail Hopkins the all time great who looked good fighting blown up welterweights.

LOL. You have to be a Joe fan. You realize that OLD ass hopkins that put Joe down is his best win right ******?

[Zmlacksz]

LOL. You have to be a Joe fan. You realize that OLD ass hopkins that put Joe down is his best win right ******?

No i'm not a joe fan but this Hopkins bull**** is getting tiresome. Jones is higher on the ATG than hopkins will ever be. Hopkins made his name Fighting at catchweights and blown up smaller fighters. Winky, Oscar, Pavlik and all the blown up fighters who moved up to fight him. You know he lost the first fight ahainst bum Mefrcado, right you english sheep-shagging related ******.

[bsrizpac]

No i'm not a joe fan but this Hopkins bull**** is getting tiresome. Jones is higher on the ATG than hopkins will ever be. Hopkins made his name Fighting at catchweights and blown up smaller fighters. Winky, Oscar, Pavlik and all the blown up fighters who moved up to fight him. You know he lost the first fight ahainst bum Mefrcado, right you english sheep-shagging related ******.

How am I English related? WHAT?

So Tarver, Johnson were smaller? Joe was smaller? cool.

[-EX-]

No i'm not a joe fan but this Hopkins bull**** is getting tiresome. Jones is higher on the ATG than hopkins will ever be. Hopkins made his name Fighting at catchweights and blown up smaller fighters. Winky, Oscar, Pavlik and all the blown up fighters who moved up to fight him. You know he lost the first fight ahainst bum Mefrcado, right you english sheep-shagging related ******.

Yet his resume is still better than Calzaghe's.

The Mercado fight was in another country with different altitude. And Bernard did well enough to get a draw even after being knocked down twice. Next...

[Patheticfraud?]

Trick question! Calzaghe's not on the all time great list....

[Patheticfraud?]

No i'm not a joe fan but this Hopkins bull**** is getting tiresome. Jones is higher on the ATG than hopkins will ever be. Hopkins made his name Fighting at catchweights and blown up smaller fighters. Winky, Oscar, Pavlik and all the blown up fighters who moved up to fight him. You know he lost the first fight ahainst bum Mefrcado, right you english sheep-shagging related ******.

Jones is a china chin, That puts him below Hopkins.

[The Surgeon]

Not close for me, HOPKINS All the way!