Who is better Miguel Cotto or Floyd Mayweather?

[larry x]

cotto is better overall,floyd's better defensively though!

how???floyds a smarter fighter,better ring generalship,better defense,more accurate,better timing

[-----------]

floyd put on 24 pounds..he fought oscar at 154

We are talking about Mayweather fighting the best at Welterweight.

And how he hasn't fought the best there.

17lbs to Welterweight.

You said Mayweather fighting the best at Welterweight is the same as Cotto fighting the best at 168. When that clearly isn't true.

Are you getting confused little boy?

[Xyei]

Cotto kicks his ass.. which is why Mayweather wont get anywhere near him.
All time wise, Mayweather's resume is better though.. Mayweather has been a pro longer then Cotto has though.

I disagree. If they ever fight I'll bet with you. I see Floyd countering the **** out of Miguel all night long and winning a clear decision. Cotto would get really frustrated not being able to hit him flush and would start making big mistakes. To each his own.

[Marvin6591]

Mayweather is better. He is far less fun to watch, and pretty mucha gigantic D-bag, but he is a more talented, well rounded fighter.

(please note that I am a Cotto fan and would always root for him.)

until now though

[THE REED]

I disagree. If they ever fight I'll bet with you. I see Floyd countering the **** out of Miguel all night long and winning a clear decision. Cotto would get really frustrated not being able to hit him flush and would start making big mistakes. To each his own.

I imagine Floyd along the ropes... Cottos attempts to goto the body, and while he does... Floyd has a field day with upper cuts.

[Sin City]

I disagree. If they ever fight I'll bet with you. I see Floyd countering the **** out of Miguel all night long and winning a clear decision. Cotto would get really frustrated not being able to hit him flush and would start making big mistakes. To each his own.

I would put all my points on the line but you and I both know it will never happen.
Mayweather prefers to fight Super Featherweights and not real threats inside his own division.

[Xyei]

I imagine Floyd along the ropes... Cottos attempts to goto the body, and while he does... Floyd has a field day with upper cuts.

Too bad the fight never happened.

[larry x]

We are talking about Mayweather fighting the best at Welterweight.

And how he hasn't fought the best there.

17lbs to Welterweight.

You said Mayweather fighting the best at Welterweight is the same as Cotto fighting the best at 168. When that clearly isn't true.

Are you getting confused little boy?

ok fine..lets see cotto at 154-160

[larry x]

I would put all my points on the line but you and I both know it will never happen.
Mayweather prefers to fight Super Featherweights and not real threats inside his own division.

lmfao..and cotto wants pacman

[Pullcounter]

floyd is better overall. all cotto has on floyd is power