Hatton P4P No. 1,2,3,4 or 5? - IF he wins May 2nd.

[123tyson123]

Number 1. If he beats the man he is the man

[gingeralbino]

I only agree with him being heavily penalized, but i think thats to do with the fashion of the loss, and then the poor performance against Lazcano. I feel he should be around 7 or 8.

I personally think p4p ratings should be based on the accomplishments you achieve outside your weight division. with that said Hatton went up to 147 and didn't really look amazing did he?

I disagree with that part. for me p4p is all about who could beat who if size wasnt an issue, so moving weight class isnt all that important. Some people can move up and down weight easier than others. Heavyweights being an obv example but its a non issue at the moment as they are all pretty ****.

However the way in which a fighter wins or loses a fight is hugely important, almost as important as the opponent(s) faced.

[Shadow boxer 3]

i say 3 or 4 IF he wins. JMM would be ahead of him till PBF whoops his ass

[Dubious-Dutch]

I disagree with that part. for me p4p is all about who could beat who if size wasnt an issue, so moving weight class isnt all that important. Some people can move up and down weight easier than others. Heavyweights being an obv example but its a non issue at the moment as they are all pretty ****.

However the way in which a fighter wins or loses a fight is hugely important, almost as important as the opponent(s) faced.

Do you believe a KO loss would affect your ranking more than a SD loss?

[JoHnNyBoXeR]

well u got marquez mayweather coming back , paul williams is in my top 5 i wouldput hattan at number 5

[gingeralbino]

Do you believe a KO loss would affect your ranking more than a SD loss?

of course, if u get dominated and KTFO its worse than losing a SD, and should affect your ranking accordingly (not just p4p but division rankings too).
If u lose a SD u were obv. competitive in the fight, and maybe even have a claim that u deserved to win, if you get KTFO after being dominated for the most part u have no such claim!

[S1MANC]

I disagree with that part. for me p4p is all about who could beat who if size wasnt an issue, so moving weight class isnt all that important. Some people can move up and down weight easier than others. Heavyweights being an obv example but its a non issue at the moment as they are all pretty ****.

However the way in which a fighter wins or loses a fight is hugely important, almost as important as the opponent(s) faced.

Sorry, not soley on accomplishments achieved outside your weight division.. obviously you have to dominate your natural class firstly then go onto to dominate fighters in other weight divisions and also different stylistic fighters to prove your pound for pound the best.

But you kind of contradict yourself, how are you gonna prove who you can beat if weight wasn't an issue - without leaving your natural weight class???

[gingeralbino]

Sorry, not soley on accomplishments achieved outside your weight division.. obviously you have to dominate your natural class firstly then go onto to dominate fighters in other weight divisions and also different stylistic fighters to prove your pound for pound the best.

But you kind of contradict yourself, how are you gonna prove who you can beat if weight wasn't an issue - without leaving your natural weight class???

Sorry didnt make myself clear, u cant prove it, its educated guess work and opinion, a bit like if Wlad were to fight Pac but they were both the same size, who would win? Thats what I mean.

I'm **** at explaining stuff by typing so apologies if I still havent made myself clear.

[KO2you]

IF Hatton beats Pac, by all means he deserves to be in the top 5 P4P. Where in that top 5 I can't say but my opinion is around #3. Until next time its KO2you

[Pugilistic™]

I think 4 or 3.