POLL: Mosley, an ATG??

[mathed]

Mosley never backed down from anyone and only lost to the best. He is a classy guy who never talks smack, he just does what he does. I say top 20 of alltime.

[Burner]

Then Roy Jones Jr isn't an ATG either? Steroids are overrated..

Tell that to Barry Bonds.....

RJ
James Toney
Mosley are all tainted.

No if ands......

[Rich Loc]

Mosley never backed down from anyone and only lost to the best. He is a classy guy who never talks smack, he just does what he does. I say top 20 of alltime.

Paul Williams..........

[BattlingNelson]

He's an ATG with an asterisk. Which ought to keep him out of the HOF.

[QUISQUEYA]

What is this a trick question? The answer is clearly yes.

Ex,

ATG?! really?

Where do you have him ranked? Top 25? Top 50? Top 100?

Do you rank him DEFINITIVELY above these guys of his generation (ish):

Whitaker
Jones, Jr
Holyfield
Hopkins
Chavez
Mayweather
Barrera
Morales
Pacquiao
Lewis
Chavez
Wright
Etc...

Can a guy be an ALL TIME great if he isn't in the top 15 of his own era?

[The_Visitation]

I've have liked a 'maybe not yet' option. He needs a couple more quality wins IMHO. It all depends how broadly you define ATG.

[-Blackout-]

Ex,

ATG?! really?

Where do you have him ranked? Top 25? Top 50? Top 100?

Do you rank him DEFINITIVELY above these guys of his generation (ish):

Whitaker
Jones, Jr
Holyfield
Hopkins
Chavez
Mayweather
Barrera
Morales
Pacquiao
Lewis
Chavez
Wright
Etc...

Can a guy be an ALL TIME great if he isn't in the top 15 of his own era?

Lol! yeah, Whatever he said

[QUISQUEYA]

Mosley never backed down from anyone and only lost to the best. He is a classy guy who never talks smack, he just does what he does. I say top 20 of alltime.

1. Top 20 is INSANE. INSANE.

2. He did steroids. Cheating. Is that classy?

Here's a top 20. Who do you take off to put Shane on?

Sugar Ray Robinson
Muhammad Al
Harry Greb
Henry Armstrong
Joe Louis
Willie Pep
Roberto Duran
Benny Leonard
Sam Langford
Jack Johnson
Jack Dempsey
Joe Gans
Sugar Ray Leonard
Gene Tunney
Bob Fitzsimmons
Jimmy Wilde
Ezzard Charles
Mickey Walker
Archie Moore
Stanley Ketchel

[Piper the Great]

Ex,

ATG?! really?

Where do you have him ranked? Top 25? Top 50? Top 100?

Do you rank him DEFINITIVELY above these guys of his generation (ish):

Whitaker
Jones, Jr
Holyfield
Hopkins
Chavez
Mayweather
Barrera
Morales
Pacquiao
Lewis
Chavez
Wright
Etc...

Can a guy be an ALL TIME great if he isn't in the top 15 of his own era?

he in the top 5 of is era.

holyfield, chavez, & whitaker not his era.

[hammerhiem]

I wouldn't go as far as top 50 but top 100 certainly.