Calzaghe vs P. Williams who wins? @ 168

[Spacey1991]

Calzaghe takes a decision in my opinion...

[sylvestersweet]

ready for some calzaghe logic? winky had a close fight with hopkins. hopkins had a close fight with calzaghe. williams dominated winky. therefore williams dominates hopkins and calzaghe.

1) triangle theory doesn't work
2) Hopkins dominated Winky just as badly as P Will
3) P will has fought twice at middleweight, one fighter coming off a two year layoff, the other named Andy Kolle.
4) P Will has never fought at super middleweight, Joe fights regularly at light heavyweight.
5) This is coming from one of Calzlappy's biggest detractors.

[optkliluzn]

LMAO did you say workrate equal.....I dont think so.....Calzaghe has NEVER thrown 1000 punches in a 12 round fight.....look it up! And yeah Winky was old and past his prime....but so was Bhop and Roy Jones so dont give me that shyt!

ive lost my faith in this site, i really have.

paul wright was excellent today, and probably a top 5 at middleweight but he fought an old, past prime winky wright. calzaghe has never lost and he has the will to never lose, he adapts all the time and has a workrate equal to paul williams, he's faster and the better boxer PLUS hes a lot bigger!

wtf!

[Ryn0]

Williams would have height, reach and maybe power?

Calzaghe would have speed, weight, higher boxing IQ, movement

Calzaghe has shown he can win if you take away his 1000+ punches a fight, Williams hasn't. Williams was excellent tonight but it's getting out of hand, Wright is not even remotely the same type of fighter and Williams. This would be one opponent Williams would not be able to outwork.

[tommy boo boxer]

im giving it to P.dub split dec


just thinking of volume punching against volume slapping will give him the judges favour.

[Ryn0]

LMAO did you say workrate equal.....I dont think so.....Calzaghe has NEVER thrown 1000 punches in a 12 round fight.....look it up! And yeah Winky was old and past his prime....but so was Bhop and Roy Jones so dont give me that shyt!

Calzaghe has, dumbass. He threw over 1000 punches against Kessler....

[boxasmash]

LMAO did you say workrate equal.....I dont think so.....Calzaghe has NEVER thrown 1000 punches in a 12 round fight.....look it up! And yeah Winky was old and past his prime....but so was Bhop and Roy Jones so dont give me that shyt!

hey dumbass

Total Punches Calzaghe Kessler
Landed 285 173
Thrown 1010 585
Percent 28% 30%

[ACHlLLES]

Hard fight to call because Calzaghe can mimic peoples styles and change his styles up while Winky is just one kind of style. Meaning, I still think a fighter who fights like quintana did in the first fight would give paul problems. Plus, Calz is the bigger man naturally in the ring and could seriously hurt Paul to the body like Calzaghe did to Kessler.

But then again, why does Williams and Dawson both have to call out older fighters like Calzaghe and Hopkins? Calzaghe still looks pretty good but still, he is old like wright and hopkins.

[ACHlLLES]

Calzaghe has, dumbass. He threw over 1000 punches against Kessler....

And Lacy, and I believe his punch-stat was high against Roy at lhw. I think it was like 800 punches against Roy Jones Jr. That poster is a dumb ****, who probably started watching boxing yesterday.

[boxasmash]

And Lacy, and I believe his punch-stat was high against Roy at lhw. I think it was like 800 punches against Roy Jones Jr. That poster is a dumb ****, who probably started watching boxing yesterday.

985 against jones and thats after noticeably letting roy go the distance after the cut in the 7th.

he let up on him majorly. he threw about 1000 against lacy