Since the start of the 90s so few fighters have more than one or two great wins

[winac]

Is holyfield great?..cause toney beat him..(yeah i know holyfield old)

That was a great win for other reasons. Holyfield was n the downside of his career

[MoneyMayFan]

Well if u put cotto on the list does that put marg on it?

[winac]

Well if u put cotto on the list does that put marg on it?

I think it would but I don't know if Cotto should go on for the SSM win

[talip bin osman]

It is true. He may have great wins but none are against truly great fighters in their prime

u seem to be hard on floyd jr sir...

u also seem to forget the great reign he had @ 130... only arguello had a better reign in that weight class...

http://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=18873

[winac]

u seem to be hard on floyd jr sir...

u also seem to forget the great reign he had @ 130... only arguello had a better reign in that weight class...

http://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=18873

no just honest. Re read the post you responded to.

[talip bin osman]

no just honest. Re read the post you responded to.

theyre the best available fighters in that weight class @ the time sir...

what more do u want from floyd @ 130?

im no floyd fan but i think he desrves a heck of a credit @ 130...

[winac]

theyre the best available fighters in that weight class @ the time sir...

what more do u want from floyd @ 130?

im no floyd fan but i think he desrves a heck of a credit @ 130...

I made the thread to avoid comments liek yours. Regardless of whether a fighter could have fought someone, should have fought someone, didn't fight someone I am only mentioning wins against truly great fighters in their primes. End of

[thebowtod]

I may hate mayweather and all, but that win over hatton is very impressive

[J.B.moneY.]

yea i agree with your list...except for floyd....floyd beat castillo the second time, first time he lost imo.....then he beat corrales, and i think hatton was a great win too

[winac]

yea i agree with your list...except for floyd....floyd beat castillo the second time, first time he lost imo.....then he beat corrales, and i think hatton was a great win too

To you and Ricky Ward. This is about beating truly great fighters in their primes. That does not include Hatton, Castillo or Corrales. Look at the names on that list. Every single one of them is an elite fighter. Pavlik was taken off for christs sake. Hopkins, Mosley, Wright, Toney, Jones, MAB, Morales, JMM, Pacquiao, De la Hoya, Trinidad. Don't disrespect those names and ame Hatton in the same breath.