What do you guys mean "all-time great" exactly?

[dans]

If Cotto keeps winning the fight will happen. And I think it will. And it will be an amazing fight to watch, I promise. As great as Mayweather is, I don't see Cotto being dominated, and I think he would push Mayweather more than he's ever been pushed, physically. But ask me who I think would win, Mayweather, he is just so damn good.

[S.G.]

"ATG" roughly translates to top 100 boxer i think

[FasTHarD]

6 time champ
5 divisions
undefeated
half his fights title fights
p4p#1
crema de la creme
all in under 10 years

But ducked the best... Kostya,Cotto,Margarito,Mosley...

[-EX-]

"ATG" roughly translates to top 100 boxer i think

What I was thinking...

[-EX-]

But ducked the best... Kostya,Cotto,Margarito,Mosley...

What u talkin bout?

[FasTHarD]

What u talkin bout?

lol so you agree he ducked Cotto, Margarito and Mosley?

[deliveryman]

To me "All Time Great" refers to fighters who would belong on the "hall of fame in the hall of fame"

[deliveryman]

lol so you agree he ducked Cotto, Margarito and Mosley?

He called out Mosley. Mosley had a toothache, remember?

[talip bin osman]

just my 2 cents...

ATG IMO, is a status beyond being "merely a HOF..."

its like comparing isiah thomas who is an ATG to gary payton who was simply just an all-star...

like roger federer to james blake...

erik morales to paulie ayala... (not sure if paulie would be an inductee though)

u know what i mean?

[-EX-]

lol so you agree he ducked Cotto, Margarito and Mosley?

Margarito sucks, Mosley turned down a fight. Floyd should have fought Cotto. Kosta was pretty much washed up and then got mauled by Hatton.