Prime Ike Quartey vs Floyd Mayweather at 147. Who'd win

[Mr.Fantastic]

Had Ike closed the show properly, no way you give that fight to dlh...no
Coincidence that dlh never rematched him

Yes way! Oscar barely won that fight. I will give you that, he didn't rematch him nor Whitaker but he at least fought them.

[djtmal]

lol, why would he??? oscar has fought a lot of really good fighters. but truth is he basically lost or could have lost every fight against anyone on or near his level.

I don't know if I would go that far...he beat Vargas clean, and a case could be made in the
Shane rematch as well as trinidad imo

[IMDAZED]

I don't know if I would go that far...he beat Vargas clean, and a case could be made in the
Shane rematch as well as trinidad imo

Vargas was a shell of himself by then, roids or no roids.

[Kagami Taiga]

I don't know if I would go that far...he beat Vargas clean, and a case could be made in the
Shane rematch as well as trinidad imo

lol, he beat vargas after trinidad ended his prime. trinidad...smh. and u have a point with shane, had him winning that. but eh

[djtmal]

Vargas was a shell of himself by then, roids or no roids.

No excuses

[Mr.Fantastic]

Vargas was a shell of himself by then, roids or no roids.

Vargas was at least over 85% of what he used to be when he got to Oscar. Being on roids should raise it more. The one that got the shell was Mosley and Vargas was still good enough to beat someone like Castillejo.

[djtmal]

One thing about those guys, not too many marquee matchups went unmade prime or close to prime

[IMDAZED]

No excuses

Not an excuse - fact. Can't pretend that wasn't the case.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

People like to rip oscar alot but the guy delivered great fights and matchups his entire career,,,

pernell
ike
tito
vargas
mosely twice
hopkins
floyd
manny

all pretty much at their peaks,,,,,

people can say he should have lost to pernell and sturm, but if you want to take those wins away, then add on the tito win and the mosely rematch win.....

All in all, oscar fought a helluva schedule, and i havent even mentioned, ruales, gatti, mayorga, genero, chavez twice, leija, molina, paez,


The ike-oscar fight was super close as oscar faded from rounds 6-11 but pulled out a huge 12th round,,,,,

Whether people like it or not,, oscar fought everyone, never dodged big event type fights, and always took the big challenges,,

floyd wont even think about going to 160 for serg or ggg,,, let alone ****ing hopkins

oscar fought 3 legit p4p #1 guys in manny, floyd, hopkins,, plus tito, pernell and shane were all p4p fighters when he fought them


I wish all fighters had the balls of oscar,,, win or lose he took the big fights

[beez721]

As much as i'd like to say Quartey for the obvious, I keep going back to how he came apart
against dlh and lopez in his prime. Fmj could outthink him
down the stretch

I thought quartey beat dlh and was a bit past it when he fought lopez who was a very big puncher