Rate the top ten heavyweights

[Klitschko2011]

Someone objecting to my list with a Klitschko username and avator holds no credibility. Here ya go slag

You threw your credibility out the window when you posted those horrible rankings.

[The Gunner]

You threw your credibility out the window when you posted those horrible rankings.

How the **** is that possible when it is an opinion thread? Do you know what opinion means? After reading your first post i think not LOL!!!!

[Chunk..]

My own rankings, I did not include Maskaev and Haye:

1. Wladimir
2. Vitali
3. Povetkin
4. Chagaev
5. Dimitrenko
6. JC Gomez
7. Arreola
8. Chambers
9. Peter
10.Valuev

I cannot put Haye in the top 10 because he's never beaten a top 15 heavyweight, just one fringe contender. Gomez losing to Vitali shouldn't cause him to drop out, after all he fought better than Peter.

Who has Arreola beat?

The fact that you HATE Haye pretty much makes your opinion of him 'Null and void'. You're never fair and objective about David Haye.

For what it's worth, i don't think Haye is top 10 either - but putting Arreola at #7 and saying Haye hasn't beat anyone to be in the top 10, stinks contradiction.

[The Gunner]

Who has Arreola beat?

The fact that you HATE Haye pretty much makes your opcion of him 'Null and void'. You're never fair and objective about David Haye.

For what it's worth, i don't think Haye is top 10 either - but putting Arreola at #7 and saying Haye hasn't beat anyone to be in the top 10, stinks contradiction.

Any fighter who unifys and moves up will very quickly take a very healthy ranking. It's just a fact and has happened time and time again.

[HeartAttack]

my rankings.

1. Wladimir Klitschko
2. Vitali Klitschko
3. Ruslan Chagaev
4. Alexander Povetkin
5. Alexander Dimitrenko
6. Juan Carlos Gomez
7. David Haye
8. Eddie Chambers
9. Chris Arreola
10. Nikolai Valuev

disclaimer time. Povetkin consistently defeats top 15-25 talent every time out. Dimitrenko scored a great ko of Krasniqi and I rate that over the Barrett victory. Gomez sent a very solid fighter in Vladimir Virchis into retirement. Haye unlike anyone else on this list, was a former champion, not titlist. Plus he has two wins at heavyweight and yes I include the Bonin fight. Valuev beat Ruiz and I give him credit for that, but he LOST to Holyfield plain and simple. Arreola is exciting and he could take down Maskaev if they fought. Chambers makes it on with his win over number 6 Peter, and his refusal to beat #4 Povetkin

[Chunk..]

Any fighter who unifys and moves up will very quickly take a very healthy ranking. It's just a fact and has happened time and time again.

Doesn't make it right though, and i'm probably Haye's biggest fan on here?

[The Gunner]

Arreola has defeated two top 50 young heavyweights: Witherspoon and Walker, as well as a number of decent journeymen.

Haye has only defeated shot old Barrett, and his home ref allowed him to fight dirty in that one (rabbit punching, hitting and holding, etc).

Haye does not impress me.

Wait until June 20, Hayemosexuals! You're in for a rude awakening.

It's a shame your boys aint as confident as you....

[The Hammer]

Who has Arreola beat?

The fact that you HATE Haye pretty much makes your opinion of him 'Null and void'. You're never fair and objective about David Haye.

For what it's worth, i don't think Haye is top 10 either - but putting Arreola at #7 and saying Haye hasn't beat anyone to be in the top 10, stinks contradiction.

Arreola has defeated two "top 50" young heavyweights: Witherspoon and Walker, as well as a number of decent journeymen.

Haye has only defeated shot old Barrett, and his home ref allowed him to fight dirty in that one (rabbit punching, hitting and holding, etc).

Haye does not impress me.

Wait until June 20, Hayemosexuals! You're in for a rude awakening.

[BattlingNelson]

But Dimitrenko also defeated other fringe contenders like Timo Hoffmann and some "top 100" ranked journeymen, like Derek Rossy.

Barrett was KOed by Cliff Couser - Krasniqi, Hoffmann and several other Dimitrenko opponents would not have been.

Hoffmann is really worthless. He fights like a statue but moves even slower.

Barrett had a good win over (the admittedly grossly overrated) Tye Fields and looked good in that.

I'm not as wellinformed as you on the heavies but I would think that Haye should be in the lower half of the top 10 just a notch under Dimitrenko.

[BattlingNelson]

my rankings.

1. Wladimir Klitschko
2. Vitali Klitschko
3. Ruslan Chagaev
4. Alexander Povetkin
5. Alexander Dimitrenko
6. Juan Carlos Gomez
7. David Haye
8. Eddie Chambers
9. Chris Arreola
10. Nikolai Valuev

disclaimer time. Povetkin consistently defeats top 15-25 talent every time out. Dimitrenko scored a great ko of Krasniqi and I rate that over the Barrett victory. Gomez sent a very solid fighter in Vladimir Virchis into retirement. Haye unlike anyone else on this list, was a former champion, not titlist. Plus he has two wins at heavyweight and yes I include the Bonin fight. Valuev beat Ruiz and I give him credit for that, but he LOST to Holyfield plain and simple. Arreola is exciting and he could take down Maskaev if they fought. Chambers makes it on with his win over number 6 Peter, and his refusal to beat #4 Povetkin

These rankings are pretty good. I could vote for those