Would Ricky Hatton go above Calzaghe if he beat Pac?

[Dynamite Kid]

Ok thanks. he was one great lightweight. I know its kinda disrespectful but he was really the "poorman's JCC" for me.a compliment really if you look at it.

Yeah i think he is an overrated fighter. He is NO atg in my book. I think Whitaker/Mosley/Duran/Arguello would beat him comfortably.

[Rich Loc]

i take it u have pacquiao winning?

I think Pacman takes a UD in a war

[goza]

Would Ricky Hatton go above Calzaghe as an ATG British great, if he beat Pac?

Hatton

Pacquiao
Tszyu
Castillo
Collazo
Urango
Malignaggi
Maussa
Tackie
Phillips
Magee
Pendleton
Lazcano
Thaxton



Joe Calzaghe

Hopkins
Kessler
Eubank
Jones
Woodhall
Ried
Mitchell
Brewer
Lacy
Sheika
Bika
Veit
Starie

he is already above Calzaghe.Seriously

[Puntoyhauf]

I'm a fan of both but i think Hatton is already ahead now.
Joe should have left Warren a long time ago, maybe he would have had the bigger fights sooner than he did.

Is that poor girl in your sig need foster care?
I'd be glad to adopt her.. there's an extra room in my house for her..LOL!

[Sparked_1985]

yeah he would be, definetely.

That sucks for Joe Calzaghe, P4P Joe Calzaghe would whomp Ricky Hatton. Sad really.

[The_Demon]

Yeah i think he is an overrated fighter. He is NO atg in my book. I think Whitaker/Mosley/Duran/Arguello would beat him comfortably.

i only have him in the top 100 as for me he beat mayweather but i can see a lot of arguments against him

[strugler]

Yeah i think he is an overrated fighter. He is NO atg in my book. I think Whitaker/Mosley/Duran/Arguello would beat him comfortably.

Yeah i see what you mean...and he was a very big lightweight am not saying it should be taken against him but its not that impressive

[Spacey1991]

Would Ricky Hatton go above Calzaghe as an ATG British great, if he beat Pac?

Hatton

Pacquiao
Tszyu
Castillo
Collazo
Urango
Malignaggi
Maussa
Tackie
Phillips
Magee
Pendleton
Lazcano
Thaxton



Joe Calzaghe

Hopkins
Kessler
Eubank
Jones
Woodhall
Ried
Mitchell
Brewer
Lacy
Sheika
Bika
Veit
Starie

Yep, Hatton has fought in a more talented division too... Calzaghe's wins against Hopkins and Jones were good but in all fairness if it happened 8 years ago it could and probably would have been different.

[Dynamite Kid]

Yeah i see what you mean...and he was a very big lightweight am not saying it should be taken against him but its not that impressive

Yeah. He was a great fighter dont get me wrong, and its a great win for Hatton, but i cant rank him really high amongst the great LW of all time though. However to reiterate he was a Very good fighter.

[Technical_Skill]

yeah he would be, definetely.

That sucks for Joe Calzaghe, P4P Joe Calzaghe would whomp Ricky Hatton. Sad really.

To be fair hatton went to the USA and risked his 0 against the best fighter of this era hands down.

Wonder what would have happened if he held on to the WBU for 10 years, staying in his backyard for most of it, and trying to get the best fighters of his era to come and fight him in some car park in manchester, then complain they are ducking him when they turn him down.