Would Ricky Hatton go above Calzaghe if he beat Pac?

[Dynamite Kid]

Would Ricky Hatton go above Calzaghe as an ATG British great, if he beat Pac?

Hatton

Pacquiao
Tszyu
Castillo
Collazo
Urango
Malignaggi
Maussa
Tackie
Phillips
Magee
Pendleton
Lazcano
Thaxton



Joe Calzaghe

Hopkins
Kessler
Eubank
Jones
Woodhall
Ried
Mitchell
Brewer
Lacy
Sheika
Bika
Veit
Starie

[The_Demon]

personally i think hes already above him,but they are both legends!

[Dynamite Kid]

personally i think hes already above him,but they are both legends!

He definelty has better names on his resume imo. Tszyu was still a good fighter when Hatton beat him. Cant say the same for Jones.

[strugler]

He wouldve fought 3 atg 2 in their prime

[The_Demon]

He wouldve fought 3 atg 2 in their prime

i would class kostya as an ATG,so that would make it 4

[UKDan]

after hatton fights pac he will have went after 2 p4p #1's both in their primes, ok yeah he lost but at least he fought dangerous fighters, beat kostya (although on the decline), and he fought the guys at the top of his weight division.....i do put this down to him leaving frank warren while he was still young!

For me calzaghe only fought lacy (hypejob) and kessler who could be considered "prime" fighters at the top of their game and then took on big names who arent as good as they were...although the hopkins win carries some weight cause he proved he had some left in the tank against pavlik, but jones looked SHOT! Joe C shud have left warren much earlier in his career and went after the biggest fights!

[Rich Loc]

Castillo > Eubank
Pacman > Hopkins
Kostya > Kessler

[strugler]

i would class kostya as an ATG,so that would make it 4

I got
KT, Pac and PBF. JLC in your ATG?

[UKDan]

Castillo > Eubank
Pacman > Hopkins
Kostya > Kessler

totally agree...hatton ranks higher for me!

[The_Demon]

I got
KT, Pac and PBF. JLC in your ATG?

IMO yes but he was past it when hatton fought him