Who will or wont rate Hatton P4P, if he beats Pacquiao ?

[P4P GOAT]

*sigh...

No, it isn't fact.

Got their in the end didn't we.

[dans]

Got their in the end didn't we.

Is it finally over? I joined in for a while but realized we weren't getting anywhere.

[S A M U R A I]

Got their in the end didn't we.

Actually, we were already there.

Maybe you could have some fun in this thread:

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=249760

100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

[P4P GOAT]

Actually, we were already there.

Why did you persist acting like some so called "experts" opinion means more than mine or anyone else's then? when it does not.

We are all entitled to our OWN opinion and we all form our opinion on different criteria and it does not always coincide with what ring magazine says, but that does not mean we are wrong to think differently, because the ring magazine are not RIGHT, because its not a factual list they are making.

There is not a right or wrong list there is people's own personal opinion.

[S A M U R A I]

Why did your persist acting like like some so called "experts" opinion means more than mine or anyone else's then? when it does not.

We are all entitled to our OWN opinion and we all form our opinion on different criteria and it does not always coincide with what ring magazine says, but that does not mean we are wrong to think differently, because the ring magazine are not RIGHT, because its not a factual list they are making.

Their is not right or wrong list there is people's own personal opinion.

You appear to have seriously misread my posts. I'm not even sure it's possible to converse with you rationally on this.

How can I say it... Ring magazine's list is one that the majority of people come close to agreeing on. That's pretty much it. Where Ricky Hatton ends up in my list, nobody cares. Where he ends up on Ring's list, many will agree on. Where he ends up on Ring's list matters to Ricky himself.

What yours or my list looks like doesn't mean anything in the grand scheme of it all. YES, P4P lists are based on opinion, but some opinions are more respected than others. You are entitled to your opinion, of course, but it's pretty much irrelevant because your opinion is not credible within the boxing world.

I'm not sure what else there is to say, and I'm not sure how you even found a problem with what I have said already.



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

[Pullcounter]

confusing poll.

hatton would be p4p top 10

he would not be top 3 and definitely not #1.

[P4P GOAT]

You appear to have seriously misread my posts. I'm not even sure it's possible to converse with you rationally on this.

How can I say it... Ring magazine's list is one that the majority of people come close to agreeing on. That's pretty much it. Where Ricky Hatton ends up in my list, nobody cares. Where he ends up on Ring's list, many will agree on. Where he ends up on Ring's list matters to Ricky himself.

What yours or my list looks like doesn't mean anything in the grand scheme of it all. YES, P4P lists are based on opinion, but some opinions are more respected than others. You are entitled to your opinion, of course, but it's pretty much irrelevant because your opinion is not credible within the boxing world.

I'm not sure what else there is to say, and I'm not sure how you even found a problem with what I have said already.

Okay so, its made up of more than one persons opinion, but its still their opinion.

"Where Ricky Hatton ends up in my list, nobody cares. Where he ends up on Ring's list, many will agree on. Where he ends up on Ring's list matters to Ricky himself"


If i had a P4P list nobody would care where Hatton ended up on my list, but guess what i wouldn't care where the ring magazine officially put Hatton, and if he gets ranked too highly in Boxing history, it still wouldn't sway the original opinion i held of him, when he was an active fighter, if he is retired by that time of coarse.

I dont listen to "so called" experts, when i score fights. I score them myself i guess im wrong to do that, if my scorecard differs from there's eh? Apparently there opinion means more than mine so =the must have it right and i must have it wrong.

Arsene Wenger/Mourinho were not professional footballers, but both have forged better managerial career's than some of these GREAT ex players who are now sports pundits and " so called experts' Majority of those pundits are failed managers at lower league clubs too. I guess Jose/Wenger were not considered experts, when they got into coaching, but guess what? there opinion is better than most players who played the game at the highest level.

Morale of the story their is not such thing as an expert.

[jimmy357]

probably #6 to #8 not more.no mas

[S A M U R A I]

Okay so, its made up of more than one persons opinion, but its still their opinion.

"Where Ricky Hatton ends up in my list, nobody cares. Where he ends up on Ring's list, many will agree on. Where he ends up on Ring's list matters to Ricky himself"


If i had a P4P list nobody would care where Hatton ended up on my list, but guess what i wouldn't care where the ring magazine officially put Hatton, and if he gets ranked too highly in Boxing history, it still wouldn't sway the original opinion i held of him, when he was an active fighter, if he is retired by that time of coarse.

I dont listen to "so called" experts, when i score fights. I score them myself i guess im wrong to do that, if my scorecard differs from there's eh? Apparently there opinion means more than mine so =the must have it right and i must have it wrong.

Arsene Wenger/Mourinho were not professional footballers, but both have forged better managerial career's than some of these GREAT ex players who are now sports pundits and " so called experts' Majority of those pundits are failed managers at lower league clubs too. I guess Jose/Wenger were not considered experts, when they got into coaching, but guess what? there opinion is better than most players who played the game at the highest level.

Morale of the story their is not such thing as an expert.

Just out of interest, how come you didnt vote in the poll?



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

[P4P GOAT]

Just out of interest, how come you didnt vote in the poll?

I never vote in my polls. I like to see what other people have selected.