Whats more significant? a win over hatton or juan diaz?

[Reggie Miller]

is this a joke???

[strugler]

is this a joke???

Why do you ask?

[Reggie Miller]

Why do you ask?

look both their resume & both their fan base and ask yourself why did you make this thread.

[strugler]

Some argues that a fresh, prime lightweight is a better win for JMM
compared to a " Hypothetical" win for Pac against
Ricky Hatton, not prime?, Overrated(according to some), lightwerlterweight.

This is with regards to JMM and Pac's overall legacy.

Wasnt disrespecting JMM in any way or form.

[Reggie Miller]

Got ya

to answer your thread: ricky hatton, based on skills and resume.

[Pullcounter]

hatton has never been defeated at 140. hatton is a big strong and heavy 140 lber.

diaz already lost at 135 to campbell. diaz is a chubby lightweight.

a win over hatton is more significant than diaz

[street bully]

Hatton.....

only 3 types think otherwise
Marquez lovers
Pacquiao haters
Morons

Diaz is a great fighter, better than most give him credit for, but only one man has dominated Hatton, and that was #1 p4p fighter, while Diaz was recently dominated by Campbell, who is good, but is #20-30.

Diaz was not "dominated" by Campbell, he won the first 5 rounds, and then was outworked for the second half of the fight. IMO Hatton lost to Collazo, struggled with a club fighter in Urango, and was Koed by Fkoyd who was P4P number one. Diaz got knocked out by the P4P number two, but fought a lot more valiemtly that Hatton. I don't think JMM could move up to 140 and fight Hatton because he is just so much bigger, but P4P Marquez destroys him. Regarding which would be the better win Diaz or Hatton, I really think they are about the same but Pacquiao hasn't won yet JMM has, so JMM has a claim to be P4P number one at the moment, if Pacquaio beats Hatton then he would probably get his spot back.

[Chase8400]

Diaz was not "dominated" by Campbell, he won the first 5 rounds, and then was outworked for the second half of the fight. IMO Hatton lost to Collazo, struggled with a club fighter in Urango, and was Koed by Fkoyd who was P4P number one. Diaz got knocked out by the P4P number two, but fought a lot more valiemtly that Hatton. I don't think JMM could move up to 140 and fight Hatton because he is just so much bigger, but P4P Marquez destroys him. Regarding which would be the better win Diaz or Hatton, I really think they are about the same but Pacquiao hasn't won yet JMM has, so JMM has a claim to be P4P number one at the moment, if Pacquaio beats Hatton then he would probably get his spot back.

Please see the colored in lines and attempt to rationalize your opinion. In my own opinion, it's very contradictory and biased. There must be a reason for you to be one of the 8-9% who dissagree with the common reasoning in the poll results. This points to you obviously being a Hatton anti-fan. It's okay, but better to just say that rather than trying to explain your off the chart opinion in detail in a failing attempt to have the people on here somehow understand the lunacy. How you think a 8 title fight (6-2) @ lw Diaz stacks up anywhere close to a 4 year lineal Jww champion with 8 title fights (7-1), 5 lineage defenses, is beyond me.

[Chups]

I'll bump this when they start hating on Hatton after May 2.

[rebmogul]

I aint gonna lie am a pacfan. who you got?and why?

but pac will lose to hatton, guaranteed......