Whats more significant? a win over hatton or juan diaz?

[-Boxzilla-]

A win over Hatton would be more significant, not way more significant but more significant nonetheless.

thats what i said more but not way more ... thats why i didnt vote cause if the wording of the pole ....

[strugler]

diaz..cause jmm actually beat him..pacman beating hatton is fantacy cause it aint happened yet..stop trying to **** on jmm win

I aint ****tin in JMMs win you ****** ****. Its a poll? how is it ****tin on JMM?

[strugler]

thats what i said more but not way more ... thats why i didnt vote cause if the wording of the pole ....

the title of the poll is "What is more significant? a win over hatton or juan diaz?"

[MANGLER]

Hatton is a bigger name and would bring Pac his next world title. Not like Diaz ain't a helluva scalp to have on your wall for JMM tho.

[larryx]

I aint ****tin in JMMs win you ****** ****. Its a poll? how is it ****tin on JMM?

cause its a dumb ass poll...jmm is the man right now let him have his moment..

[Chase8400]

Your poll is completely biased. JMM hasn't even moved up to 140 yet. What happens if JMM beats 2 top 10 140 lbs where as Pac just beats Hatton?

If you are going to be comparing victories when both fighters have recently fought at the same weight class, only the victories from those weight classes should be compared when one fighter JUST finished a fight and plans to move to the weight class the other moved to.

JMM plans to fight at 140. Make this poll when they've both compaigned at 140.

I'm sure that not everyone who voted for Hatton as being a more significant win is a Manny P. fan. The fellow who made the poll didn't bring any specific weight class into the equation. He just wanted to basically know which win is more relevant. I choose Hatton for a number of obvious reasons. Mainly being that he is the lineal Jww champion who has only lost to the very best and ducks nobody. Diaz, while a very good fighter, is nowhere near the fighter or earner that Hatton is. Not even in the same league. He lost to Cambell who is a decent fighter too, but nothing special. Diaz is not even considered the best behind Marquez in the division so how would he possibly be a better win than Hatton , who is a lineal champ and is undefeated at the weight, would be?

[Chase8400]

I picked Diaz over Hatton based on the fact that Diaz is in his prime and Hatton is not.

Okay, and what age do you consider prime? lol. And do you think Diaz would stand even a remote chance in beating Ricky Hatton?

[strugler]

cause its a dumb ass poll...jmm is the man right now let him have his moment..

Youre getting to sensitive.
This isnt a JMM should fight CJ or a JMM is overrated thread
Its a poll. choices were exactly worded the same.

[$partacus]

The people saying Diaz is a better fighter and would beat Hatton are just being ******, i don't think they actually believe what they're saying themselves.

[strugler]

you would have to be out on day release to think diaz is more significant than Hatton infact you would have to av missed your medication to even post this thread, Diaz deserves a rematch wi JMM but he is in no way on Hattons level, not yet anyway.

Thats why its called a boxing forum smart guy, to discuss everybody's opinion even yours.