Why Pacquiao vs Marquez Trilogy Won't Decide who's Better

[loui_ludwig]

Everybody who wasn't a pinoy had him winning the second match.

No wait, even Nonito Donaire had Marquez winning the second match........

And they also said that it was a closed fight that could have gone either way. Except of course for the Pac haters, the haters have JMM winning widely.

It was a closed fight. Get over it. Pac beat JMM and if the judges mistake was corrected in the 1st fight, Pac would have beat him split decision. Stop crying over it.

[ChiRock773]

And they also said that it was a closed fight that could have gone either way. Except of course for the Pac haters, the haters have JMM winning widely.

It was a closed fight. Get over it. Pac beat JMM and if the judges mistake was corrected in the 1st fight, Pac would have beat him split decision. Stop crying over it.

its all water under the bridge..but marquez did beat pacman..

[MANGLER]

The score is 1-0-1 for Pac, and it should really be 2-0. If he beats JMM decisively, it'll show he's the better man. If JMM wins, even if it's decisive, the score becomes 1-1-1, and some cats will still point to that and say they'd have to fight again. Unless JMM's decisive win was by a KO, then **** it, JMM>Pac and nobody could argue ****.

[dde91]

The score is 1-0-1 for Pac, and it should really be 2-0. If he beats JMM decisively, it'll show he's the better man. If JMM wins, even if it's decisive, the score becomes 1-1-1, and some cats will still point to that and say they'd have to fight again. Unless JMM's decisive win was by a KO, then **** it, JMM>Pac and nobody could argue ****.

Then thats when i come in and Say Pac is shot because he is over thirty and he is past prime.

[DarchinyFAN]

Unfortunatly for people who say Marquez won, they only have their opinion, history has Pacquiao winning the 2nd fight. I mean the rules are if the fight finishes the judges score it, **** job or not (I didnt like the draws in John v Juarez or Cintron v Martinez for example), but we cant go around saying results aren't results because we don't like them. Was a close fight, and judges went with Pac.

I'm not sayin, I'm just sayin.... in the words of Ron Burgundy its science.

[Fights]

What if the 3rd fight was made a 15 rounder?

The outcome would still be close.

[Lady Fan]

Marquez is already known as the better boxer.

Okay, if you say so...

[Fights]

Hope this fight gets made at 135 this year...should be a great fight

If Pac loses to Hatton, then this might be possible.

If not, well, you already know the answer.

[Boxingelite]

If Pac loses to Hatton, then this might be possible.

If not, well, you already know the answer.

No if Hatton wins .....JMM should fight Hatton.

[Michelle21]

Pac beat JMM twice...

the first fight was a robbery... after the judge admitted he ****ed up the scoring..

the 2nd fight is a SD..