Roach is Not Concerned With Ricky Hatton's Body Attack

[Dave Rado]

bias yes arrogance no i dont care how you divide it there is no way pakya number 1 pnd for pnd now

No, you're arrogant. Boxing experts aren't infallible, they can be wrong, and if you were to say "I appreciate that all the boxing experts rate him at #1 P4P but I don't see it", that's okay, but to say "all the boxing experts are ****** and I'm right and they're wrong" is outrageously arrogant. Boxing experts can sometimes be wrong, but they are right about boxing more often than you or I are - that's why they're called boxing experts.

[start11]

cmon dude judges often wrong all the sudden they are convienently wise and just because its a pac fight cmon please,, look at the toney vs oquendo or berto vs collazo matches. that shoulda been a draw or a loss 4 berto,but since hbo is trying to make berto the next hot **** the judges are often lenient to put it kindly.what i cant accept is credit where its not really due.pacya way overrated u know this but enjoy it while it lasts hey all lose sooner or later. jmm vs diaz thats a tough one if jmm hasnt aged should win but this is boxing weve had like 5 major upsets in a row

That is why im enjoying while he is still there willing to fight even cotto or mosley... The little guy has a gut somehow...

It will be more controversial if JMM won that fight though... That is the reason why it was called razor thin SD...

[strugler]

pak jumped weights true but the quality of opposition diaz and delahoya wernt top guys the way pavlik was or hopkins , dlh wasnt the great delahoya that pac beat delahoya was incredible regardless. ,jmm beat casamayor, juarez recently and barrera all at better stages in their careers than diaz or delahoya,i dont buy that pac a feather weight hes really a 140 lber that can lose weight cuz hes come in heavier repeatedly at fight time in his last 10 fights at feather lite weight and even at welter.id say calzage would have to be tops even though i think his punching weird id actually have pak and jmm tied at three and sugar shane at 2 because of how he destroyed marg ,pretty clearly dominated welter ,except for williams but he finished stronger than williams williams won on points early rnd buildup.i dunno

MAn Casamayor is old, and was competetive the whole fight.Dont get me started with barrera he was KD it wasnt called.competetive fight. This is the same barrera who pac ****d in his prime. going up. you dont buy pac is a featherweight so erics first win doesnt count. Joe based on what? bernard or Roy? LMAO. Its your list ... Williams there?

1, JOE
2.Shane
3-4 JMM and pac

[strugler]

No, I think he will win. He did not fight Quintana again because he blew him out inside a round. The same reason RJJ did not fight Montell Griffin again.

You were discussing boxing?? Oh, you mean repeatedly asking the same question about P4P in broken English?? Great job. Max Kellerman look out, this guy is coming for your job. Stop writing "LMAO", it makes you look like a ******.

LMAO

I thought you were going away? ha ha ha. The last time i checked score was 1-1 dont you think we need nother one? LMAO.

[fcastro1]

why is it always hate? there are plenty of active fighters with a more impressive resume whom got their big wins against fighters in their primes .

name me one active fighter with a better resume than pac???

[boxinguitarfan]

That is why im enjoying while he is still there willing to fight even cotto or mosley... The little guy has a gut somehow...

It will be more controversial if JMM won that fight though... That is the reason why it was called razor thin SD...

cotto or mosley destroy pac hes confident cause he thinks all welter will do nothing like delahoya ,but thats not likely.as far as jmm he landed more and took the championship rnds wouldnt of been contreversial at all punch stats vs opinion i dunno no more pk vs jmm 2 jmm won the compubox and had pak not seeing out of his eye the last rnd due to a punch, pacs knockdown vs more landed shots and more rnds, sleeptime

[strugler]

cotto or mosley destroy pac hes confident cause he thinks all welter will do nothing like delahoya ,but thats not likely.as far as jmm he landed more and took the championship rnds wouldnt of been contreversial at all punch stats vs opinion i dunno no more pk vs jmm 2 jmm won the compubox and had pak not seeing out of his eye the last rnd due to a punch, pacs knockdown vs more landed shots and more rnds, sleeptime

i think they would , i give mad props for even considering fighting them welterweights, i stil think pac has a chance though

[boxinguitarfan]

mosley ,hopkins ,jmm,barerra cotto winky wright,thosefighters have wins against fighters in their primes not old shot dudes or draws and too close to calls. more kos against more champs. last in his prime elite fighter pac dominated was barrera,since then its been a rough ride!

[start11]

FINALLY somebody with some real input and not just "Oh Pacquiao destroys Hatton because he's the better boxer" Or "Pacquiao would beat Cotto" or "Pacquiao would beat Godzilla, King Kong and the Clover Field Monster" I think Manny Pacquiao is a very entertaining, tough, fast, aggressive fighter but he didn't even stay at 135 long enough to get really tested. I'm sure there are some guys there that would put Manny on his ass. On top of that both his fights with JMM are questionable (Not saying I think so) but damn! Manny had two times to put this much older guy he knocked down a total of 4 times out of there and still made it questionable wins?

Come on guys! I like Manny too but clearly everyone with an opinion opposite to "Manny is the greatest" is not wrong but just very observant and sees the big picture. Not saying Manny couldn't beat a lot of guys bigger and stronger than him but he hasn't and struggled with a game older one at 130 2x. I want to see more of him dominating before I crown this guy because realistically I feel 140 is going to eat him alive.

Ok just be sure that you will be here after may 2... Let see if your predictions are true that he will be eaten alive at 140...

This would be a war... Both of them will certainly strugle and both of them have a chance... I just dont see it that hatton has a better chance... I will favor pacquiao on this...

[hammerhiem]

name me one active fighter with a better resume than pac???

More to the point name one with a better resume in the last 2-3 years which is what is being judged here.