Who Is Ranked Higher On The ATG List of These 3? (Mosley, Oscar & Tito)

[Darkstar]

De La Hoya's Lightweight run easily was better than Mosley's.
I thought he beat Trinidad, Mosley II, and won the Quartey fight because of the knockdown. had the Whitaker fight a Draw.

then throw in his wins over Miguel Angel Gonzalez and Genaro Hernandez(the first man to beat either of them).

Oscar and Mosley both beat Mayorga and Vargas...so I think De La Hoya's run at 154 was better too, because I thought he beat Mosley there and also had that win over Castellejo and Campas.

its not out of reach for Mosley to eclipse De La Hoya, but I think De La Hoya is ahead as of right now.

Yep. I agree with that.

All three are very good and will forever be linked to one another. Their isnt too much separation between them.

[Pullcounter]

i voted for tito... tito was on a tear until he met hopkins and retired. I dont really count anything past hopkins.

mosley is next because he only lost to 2 guys

oscar is last because he got whupped by a former 106 lber

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Tito>>>>>DLH>>>>>>Mosley!!!!!!!!!!!!

Titos Key wins
Blocker
Withaker
Campas
Carr
DLH
Reid
Vargas
Joppy
Mayorga

DLH Key wins

Gonzalez
Molina
Whitaker
JCC
Quartey
Carr
Vargas
Mayorga
Sturm

Mosleys key wins
Molina
Hollyday
DLH
Vargas
Collazo
Margarito

[NAPO]

i fail to see how is mosley better than trinidad on ATG status.

[xfiles]

Hard to say, It's easy to pick Mosley because he just won a big fight but I don't know. Trinidad had a great run and Delahoya had his day. I,d probably go with Mosley or maybe Trinidad. Don't forget Mosley did use steroids. That effects his ranking.

[Mr. Fantastic]

All three are very good and will forver be linked to one another. Their isnt too much separation between them.

I agree with this. All 3 are ATGs in my book, they didn't fear fighting the best unlike other boxers.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I agree with this. All 3 are ATGs in my book, they didn't fear fighting the best unlike other boxers.

I totally agree with you here!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Mr. Fantastic]

Tito>>>>>DLH>>>>>>Mosley!!!!!!!!!!!!

Titos Key wins
Blocker
Withaker
Campas
Carr
DLH
Reid
Vargas
Joppy
Mayorga

DLH Key wins

Gonzalez
Molina
Whitaker
JCC
Quartey
Carr
Vargas
Mayorga
Sturm

Mosleys key wins
Molina
Hollyday
DLH
Vargas
Collazo
Margarito

Don't forget titles in different weight divisions, defenses. Don't forget to add Hernandez too for DLH. It all kinda evens out in the end.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Don't forget titles in different weight divisions, defenses. Don't forget to add Hernandez too for DLH. It all kinda evens out in the end.

Tito a 3 division Champ, he unified 2 and Dominate 2
17 Titles defenses at WW Completely dominating the division
Unified SWW Champ
And was only the second WW in boxing history to win a title in his first title fight at MW.

Hes only losses cames to the hands of bigger man at 160 and at 170

Trinidad resume

Blocker
Campas
Camacho
Carr
Barnes
Whitaker
DLH
Reid
Thiam
Vargas
Joppy
Mayorga


DLH is a 6 division champ, unified 1, didnt dominate any.
Lost his biggest fights against Trinidad, Mayweather,Mosley Pacquaio,Hopkins.

4 of his 5 loses came to smaller men.

DLH Resume
Hernandez
Whitaker
Camacho
JCC
Gonzalez
Gatti
Vargas
Mayorga
Campas
Castillejo
Sturm

Carr,Vargas,Campas and Mayorga all after Tito Knock them the **** out!!!!!!!!

[S.G.]

but Oscar beat Tito though.