Who Is Ranked Higher On The ATG List of These 3? (Mosley, Oscar & Tito)

[KESSLER]

He really does.

I cant really blame him for quitting against Manny. He had nothing left, at all.

Whatsoever.

Manny was completely and utterly beating him to a pulp.

Prime Oscar would have killed him. 135lbs Oscar vs. 135lbs Manny Pacquiao.... Oscar would kill him.

[PUERTORICANBEN]

...he's like cotto, all ability, no heart...you can't be an atg when you fold under pressure...or quit in plain english...mosley is the only one of these 3 that has heart...



Kabuki joe

joe, you scare me when you say cotto and trinidad have no heart. You sure you watch boxing? I mean tito was made a legend for having heart. Hes got the same heart holyfeilds got! He battled every fight and miguel also has shown he has heart. He was in trouble against shane, zab, torres and chorley so i guess you just might be a hater. To say they dont have heart is to say tyson didnt have punching power...and i dont see how people can pick oscar over tito.....oscar made more money and was the golden boy, but whod he beat? I mean come on the guy hasw made a name by losing to the best fighters!!! He was beat by both other guys on this list, never wanted to fight tito again and settlke the score, quit against manny and trinidad, and doesnt have a quality win in god knows how long...its not a popularity contest. To be honest. Dlh was an average fighter, and when you compare his style to other mexicans you see why he rode the american side of things. Hes a smart man, but in the ring he doesnt stand up to mosely or trinidad in both head to head bouts and talent

[rizkybizness]

Prime Oscar would have killed him. 135lbs Oscar vs. 135lbs Manny Pacquiao.... Oscar would kill him.

the thought of manny facing a prime oscar makes me LOL

[KESSLER]

the thought of manny facing a prime oscar makes me LOL

Oscar De La Hoya was a beast in his prime.

[Testdead]

Oscar fought the best but lost to nearly all of them. I gotta go with Mosley here.

[MANGLER]

SSM just boosted his legacy wit the Marg win. He's doin better at the end of his career than DLH and Felix, and he's the better overall fighter than both.

[hookoutofhell]

sugar shane imo is the best of the lot, damn man if that guy could control his pride hed be a ATG by now without doubt. but he always gets drawn into battles and goes toe to toe.

i think hes best of the lot, followed closely by tito and then oscar comes in at a distant third.

[TheCheetah]

Oscar De La Hoya

[Steak]

De La Hoya's Lightweight run easily was better than Mosley's.
I thought he beat Trinidad, Mosley II, and won the Quartey fight because of the knockdown. had the Whitaker fight a Draw.

then throw in his wins over Miguel Angel Gonzalez and Genaro Hernandez(the first man to beat either of them).

Oscar and Mosley both beat Mayorga and Vargas...so I think De La Hoya's run at 154 was better too, because I thought he beat Mosley there and also had that win over Castellejo and Campas.

its not out of reach for Mosley to eclipse De La Hoya, but I think De La Hoya is ahead as of right now.

[S.G.]

De La Hoya's Lightweight run easily was better than Mosley's.
I thought he beat Trinidad, Mosley II, and won the Quartey fight because of the knockdown. had the Whitaker fight a Draw.

then throw in his wins over Miguel Angel Gonzalez and Genaro Hernandez(the first man to beat either of them).

Oscar and Mosley both beat Mayorga and Vargas...so I think De La Hoya's run at 154 was better too, because I thought he beat Mosley there and also had that win over Castellejo and Campas.

its not out of reach for Mosley to eclipse De La Hoya, but I think De La Hoya is ahead as of right now.

^ what he said